Interesting fic. I like it. ^_^

that was cool. i wondered what people would think of those to. interesting POV

Indeed, he should go back to battle.
But now we can see the whole fight in a total diffrent angle. And is interesting to read, in my oppinion ^^
(Still, I think he didn't get everything right there XD)

It was AMAZING! So very literature like. I couldn't take my eyes off every word. And your ending was wonderful... such a simple point, yet explained in such a beautiful manner.

Oh... I am stunned. The skill with which you shape your words rivals that of an Elven archer, or a Dwarven metalsmith. There was an undeniable grace and quality in this story that sets it as far from the common dross as a battle-axe from a mining pick: technically the same, but truly so very different. *applauds*

Ooh. That was pure beauty. You paint such a vivid, delightful picture with your words, it's easy to forget that this is a story to read, not watch. This is a perspective I haven't seen them from before, and it's remarkable on quite a few levels. Very elegently and delightfully done.

That was beautiful.

The image of Gimli as a ferocious warrior (thankfully *not* as comic relief) was a big heck-yeah moment for all us dwarf fanciers, or at least it was for this one. Thank you for it. [I'd originally submitted this comment to the MEFAwards voting, but I wanted to copy it here, just in case you weren't reading that site. I really enjoyed this story.]

Awesome! I loved it! Wonderful, wonderful realistic descriptions of Gimli and Legolas in a time of battle. Such a simple fic, yet so powerful. Definite commendations to you, a very nice treat.

wow...this was just about perfect. Can't see a single thing wrong...and it's so cool! Really good author...wish i could write like this...*sigh* Congrats!

VERY GOOD!! I love it! Great descriptions. Sorry about the short review, I just can't think of anything else to say, your story is so perfect. Here, I can make it longer! I love your story I love your story I love your story! LOL!

um...well...interesting...

simply awsome

Wow. Very nice.
Excellent descriptions - the imagery was amazing. I like the fact that you seem to go beyond the images the movies have presented us with. And way not to be a Gimli-hater. _Thank_ you!

This is wonderful!! Very well done indeed. You've captured a viewpoint that is not represented in Tolkien's work in a way that Tolkien, I think, would have no trouble owning. Good work!