 CaptainDeloris 2009-07-13 . chapter 1my word, you are god at what you do, deary. |
 RebeccaRoy 2009-01-28 . chapter 1I adored this! Too funny really and the banter was just perfect! |
 Insane Yet Logical 2007-11-19 . chapter 1Snape talking to a wall, even before getting drunk... love it! Keep writing, I love your perspective of Snape, it's quite unique. And I've read many many snape fics. |
 Brightbear 2007-08-02 . chapter 1Snape and Sirius arguing. They do it so well. |
 raya-macgiver 2007-05-02 . chapter 1This was great! Great great great!
When Sirius knocked on Severus' door, I was a bit afraid that your story would turn into slash. I'm really glad it didn't.
Anyway, it was really well written and in character.
Loved it. |
 Lady Liadan 2007-03-21 . chapter 1Fabulous story that keeps all the characters wonderfully in their respective personas. Snape's wry humor and utter cynicism are wonderfully captured as are Sirius' braggardoccio and (unrequited) Gryffindor nobility. I also loved your depiction of Lucius (all outward appearance, whether it's the dungeons or his exposure to the minister at having lost his prisoner).
This surely reads like an authentic tale from the Order of the Phoenix' archives... |
 sumomo0476 2006-07-21 . chapter 1Excellent fic, Mariner! It's always a joy to find writers who keep the characters "in character" and yet adding a deeper dimension to them. And I do commend your writing skills. ^_^ |
 tinkabella feyd 2006-07-01 . chapter 1Wonderfully written. Sirius and Severus are so much in character, I´ve enjoyed every word. It could even be perfectly canon in a way. Maybe Harry never knew about it, because... honestly, would Sirius ever tell him? :-D LOL
So bad my english is not good enough to try and write some stuff. I only write in spanish so I can´t share with you my personal Snape and Black.
X |
 wynnleaf 2006-03-09 . chapter 1I do love this one -- every time I read it! |
 Golum 2006-02-28 . chapter 1I've reread this a couple times now and have always enjoyed it. The part about Misery, Company, and Agony is particularly great. |
 Nightmare 2005-12-28 . chapter 1 I have to say, excellent job. You potrayed the characters very well and have a wonderful plot to add to that. I do hope that the rest of your stories are just as good. |
 Pickledishkiller 2005-10-02 . chapter 1Nice. That was exceptionally well written, you rock. |
 Persephone Lupin 2005-09-11 . chapter 1Great story, loved it! Very well written and everybody perfectly in character, even the wall, LOL. |
 XiaoGui 2005-09-06 . chapter 1Oh that was nice, I enjoyed reading it. It's maybe old and AU (certainly), but it's still a nice read. Thanks a lot! :-) |
 TheDeathChamber 2005-06-22 . chapter 1The wall didn't have a word to say all night. Nice. |