|Reviews for Whether Or Not You Should|
| MuggleCreator 4/15/13 . chapter 1
In the movie scenes, I relived them...
| Cammie Cassia Chase 11/23/12 . chapter 1
I love it. That's so sweet!
| jessica97 11/11/12 . chapter 1
Beautiful! I loved it!
| Mac21 11/8/12 . chapter 1
Oh. My. Goodness. This was so great! I can't even begin to say how much I love this story! You did a beyond wonderful job! So great!
| BrittanyLS 11/6/12 . chapter 1
There are only a few stories I have read that have fully captured the romance of Maria and Georg,... and you have done it and more! Absolutely beautiful!
| Charley Paige 11/3/12 . chapter 1
Aw! This was beyond adorable and although it was really long, I still didn't want it to to end (just like every other fic of yours I've read). A very well done!:)
| hLaurie1234 11/2/12 . chapter 1
Really lovely :) Great that you've added some scenes in, they would have definitely fit in with the film. Beautifully written, as always. I would love to see something from you again soon. I miss your writing. Thank you for sharing. :) x
| Mie779 11/1/12 . chapter 1
Oh my my, what a WONDERFUL story you have written here... must say it is the BEST version of the gazebo scene (and what comes after;) that I have EVER read :D and there have been quit a few attempts to write out this part of the movie. You gave the whole scene new life that I have not found anywhere else. And made Maria's insecurity believable with out overdoing it, (hope you understand what I mean, sometimes it's hard to express what you think and feel, when English is not my first language ;) words can't describe how much I loved reading this story, stopped doing anything else on the computer while reading. I sometimes multitask when reading a story, playing a little facebook game, then reading, then back to game, then read a bit... sorry but that's just how I "work"/read at my computer:/... but your story made me forget it all and I kept reading it ALL in one go ;) :P
I really love the moment they throw the whistles into the lake... marking the beginning of their NEW life together. WELL DONE :D and the proposal at the end, just fantastic... LOVE IT ;)
| missmillie13 11/1/12 . chapter 1
Nothing like a pure lovely romance like this to brighten the day! Thank you so much for writing it... Your writing is just perfect :) Keep doing it forever more!
| augiesannie 10/31/12 . chapter 1
very cute! No such thing as too many gazebo stories, and I like the way we find out what happened the next day.
| pussycatwithattitude 10/31/12 . chapter 1
I especially loved the "afterwards" that was lovely and so in character. It is always good to see more stories from you, please write more soon.
| AndromedaAiken 10/31/12 . chapter 1
I thought I had missed a story of yours just before I turned off my computer but turns out that you just posted it up before I logged off! Consequently, I read it in bed. LOVELY WORK!
| elphabastwin 10/30/12 . chapter 1
Okay, so there were just so many things that I loved about this piece... too many to name! But I will list of some of my favorites: Maria and Georg's parallel thoughts throughout the entire thing, just the general theme I felt of their masks being taken away and their true selves revealed, and your different approach to how Georg reveals to the children that Maria will be their mother; it was also wonderful that you put the proposal in! Though we usually assume that Maria agrees to marry him after the gazebo scene, he never does formally ask her, and I love that you wrote it. The scene itself was lovely... in one of Maria's favorite places, nothing too fancy, just perfect and comfortable for her. There were also a lot of great characterization bits that I enjoyed, like Maria jumping around in the study; I could completely imagine that and it made me laugh. I'd have to say that the scene I liked the most was the part when they're talking about how the Baroness left; perhaps strange of me, but you captured their emotions so perfectly in that section - hope, relief, vulnerability - that it just left me stunned.
I'm usually not a big fan of long one shots, but as usual, with your writing I found myself adoring this one. I've read versions of this scene many times, but with the details you added, along with the descriptions of emotion most definitely made this one my favorite. As always, can't wait to read more from you!
| Becky215 10/30/12 . chapter 1
Lovely, lovely. I always enjoy your updates, and after a grueling few days at school (plus a hurricane!), this was a welcome vacation from reality. Please keep 'em coming-you're one of my favorite writers on the site and always present tremendous work.
| Katie 10/30/12 . chapter 1