Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: A Father's Wish - Page 4 of 13
cutemara 5/31/03 . chapter 12
Please, please, please continue this.
Angel 5/17/03 . chapter 12
Please update soon! I'm dying to know what happen next... I'm begging you :0)
Lady Celebwen 5/8/03 . chapter 12
Just one question: is this story going updated soon?

I really love the storyline. The plot is quit original and I like it very much.

Anxiously awaiting new chapters!
cutemara 4/20/03 . chapter 1
I love your story!
Angel 4/1/03 . chapter 12
I love your story! Especially the scenes with Celeborn and Galadriel. I love that couple! Please post soon...
stearchica 3/18/03 . chapter 12
update! !update! !update! !update! !update! !update! !update! !update!

i love this story! its amazing!
Ponytail Goddess 3/17/03 . chapter 12
Poor Celeborn didn't get the chance to state what he wanted to... Wow, this story is truly amazing in my eyes. I love it, though I also think that you slightly rushed death of Feanor. Perhaps I didn't understand it correctly though in the book.

I also like Artanis' little flings with Glorfindel. I wonder what he will have to say about Celeborn, or perhaps he will die before he has a chance to do so. I don't know; I'm not the author.

Anyways, I really enjoyed this. I hope you update very soon. I think I might go crazy if you fail to do this. Wonderful job!

-P.G.
Aredhel Ereinionchil 2/22/03 . chapter 12
This is a wonderful story! You must really write more!
Spirit Star 1/17/03 . chapter 12
*is happy* Oh, another chapter! Thank you, you've made my day
isabelle 1/11/03 . chapter 12
i've been looking for more celeborn and galadriel fics nd im soo glad i found dis! it's really good keep up the good work_till ur next update!
Hellga 1/9/03 . chapter 6
Sorry, just realized how inattentive I was, it is more than one chapter. I am very ashamed. Can I be forgiven considering the fact it is 3 in the morning here? I will be back later when I have read it all. Might be a few months, though... :(
Hellga 1/9/03 . chapter 1
Very nice... though doesn't it say explicitly that Artanis disliked Feanaro? Of course, that could come later... And the other thing that makes it just a little less than perfect, long time passed for Eldar between teh children, so Finrod would be very much an adult when Galadriel was born...
Soledad too lazy to log in 1/9/03 . chapter 12
Speaking of politics, huh? Poor Celeborn, every time he pulls his courage together in order to become a little romantic, affairs of state interfere.

Still loving your Avari a great deal. Hopefully, we'll see them later again.
Ithilwen too lazy to log in 1/8/03 . chapter 12
Another nice chapter; you handle the complexities of Beleriand politics quite well, and balance them nicely with nore personal moments that really illuminate these characters as people. So Thingol is searching out spies now - and naturally, his prejudices are causing him (and his advisors) to look in all the wrong places. And Galadriel is being drawn ever deeper into the webs he, and the other leaders of Beleriand, are now spinning. I'm looking forward to the next chapter (although not to the death of Galadriel's poor brothers).
Starlight10 1/7/03 . chapter 12
I'm glad you updated. I have been following this story, and I have to say I just love it. You have managed to maintain the mystery in both Galadriel and Celeborn's characters and personalities; perhaps, that is why I was so glad the messenger interrupted Celeborn before he said anything else to Galadriel! I am extremely curious and can hardly wait to see how you will handle "the moment" when they realize they are in love.

I also loved the mention of the legend of Arien and Tilion. Great work!
186 found: « Prev Page 1 .. 2 3 4 5 6 7 .. 13 Next »
Return to Top