Ouch. That pulled out my heart and stomped on it!
I like the 'choose your own brother' format, but you've really captured the survivor's hopelessness and despair here. For me the survivor is Dean because I keep seeing him grieving over Sam in All Hell Breaks Loose.
Gorgeously done.

btw - I loved your confession; I've done that too ;)

Oh goodness no! Will Death never loose his skeletal grip on our boys?

Bev x

heartbreaking.

Good job, but way scary. Glad you didn't use names. That would be too hard! :)