 Igenlode 12/30/03 . chapter 5 Loved it. Funny and sweet and true - which is the
last combination of adjectives, frankly, I'd ever
expect to be able to apply to a story with
Severus Snape in it! Loved the pictures...
...up until the last quarter-page, when it
suddenly goes round a corner and seems to become
something rather unrelated. I mean, the
last chapter's a rather different kind of beast
from the rest, but it still fits. It just takes
on a more bitter edge. As a happy ending, though,
that final section of it doesn't seem to have
much to do with the main story at all. And if it
isn't an attempt at a happy ending then what _is_
it for?
And why is the final picture apparently a shot of
Lily and Baldric, who haven't appeared in any
scenes together, let alone at that point?
Loved it all the same.
Thanks to Rebecca Webb for pointing me in this
direction. |
 Madame Oubliette 12/18/03 . chapter 1Wow. Someone on pointed me in the direction of your fic - and boy am I glad they did! The illustrations are amazing, and really capture the characters personalities. And the story? Well, usually I steer well clear of lily/sev - this is the first one I have brung myself to read - but you've converted me! Well written and original, love the idea of jock!lily :) |
 KatieScarlet 11/23/03 . chapter 1WOW! This was poignant, funny, touching, sad, squee-inducing, Snapeariffic, and just plain awesome. *worships* |
 Shimizu Hitomi 11/23/03 . chapter 5Dude. I really love the voice in your writing. I am speechless. |
 whipper 11/10/03 . chapter 5 hilarious. and sad. warming. and heartbreaking. i'm so very, very impressed. |
 anon 11/2/03 . chapter 5 *sniffle* This fanfic has a thoroughly sweet ending, I love it so much. And damn girl, you can draw! *turns green* |
 Person 10/26/03 . chapter 5 That was really a great story! I love how you represent the marauders et al. Really interesting interpretation!
Your illustrations are absolutely beautiful! (You should be illustrating for J.K.R's books!) |
 Juliet Songbird 10/20/03 . chapter 1 I think I'm gonna cry. I just read the whole thing, pics and all. It's so sad, she almost got the best kiss of her life.
(sigh)
Incredible story, great pics. I love Severus, he looks yum.
Juliet Songbird |
 The Sharpest Thorn 9/27/03 . chapter 5I have read this particular story far to many times that would be good for my mental health, but I still love it to bits.- I love the illustratons, the bitter-sweet ending, and the funny parts thrown in for good measure. Love it! Do more of the like. Pweaase?
Cheers,
Ivy |
 Faerie Green 9/27/03 . chapter 5This story was oddly touching. I've always thought that this might be one of the reasons why Snape and James hated each other so much, and I really like your telling of it. Very emotional in a good sense of the word. |
 Deeble 9/25/03 . chapter 5What a lovely, sad story - and the illustrations are perfect beyond words. When I think of Snape now, I see your creation. |
 Mozenwrathe 9/19/03 . chapter 5 That was absolutely beautiful - illustrated or not.
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU.
I do hope to read more tales like this one. Snape rules, but I never thought of him as a duellist. Thanks for throwing that in!
Mozenwrathe
fan of all things well written |
 An Anti-Sheep Cheese Muffin 9/13/03 . chapter 5I absolutely love your writing and your artwork I read the illustrated version and I cried at the end it was so moving and I couldn't take my eyes off it! Right after I finished I sent the link to your story to everyone I knew so they can read it too! Congratulations on this beautifully written story! D |
 Mary Sue's Evil Twin 9/11/03 . chapter 5 I enjoy your stories and pictures so very much.
More? Please? |
 Alriadne 9/4/03 . chapter 5Oh! I saw your illustrations and 've seen your elwood, either it's you or you draw exactly like someone there with the same subject. That was such a cute story. Please write more ::puppy dog eyes:: |