I was not expecting Shadow's last line, at all. I feel like I should of, it was so obvious, but I didn't.

My problem is that I usually don't feel sad after sad stories, it's just not how I seem to work. I subconsciently seem to know that none of these stories are real, so I can never truely feel for the characters. But the end of this story actually *gasp* made me sad. Just thinking about Sonic's face after Shadow saying that plot-twisting line (slightly) broke my heart.

I would just like to thank you for writing such an amazing story -- +1 on my Favourite Authors list.

First of all, I apologise for reviewing my own story! It's not something I usually do, but I feel in this instance that I need to publicly set the record straight re: UltimateSonicFan1's review of 20 April 2008.

The reason for the similarity between "Reincarnation" and "Tails' Gift" is that Mew3692002's story is almost a direct copy of mine. I received a nice review from him on 19 July 2006, and on looking at his profile, found the story "Tails' Gift", published 9 June 2006. (All dates are available on the appropriate profile, story, and review pages.) I requested that he post a disclaimer stating that "Tails' Gift" was based on "Reincarnation" (published 18 August 2002, four years previously), which he did: this disclaimer is actually in the summary of "Tails' Gift". Satisfied by this, I let the matter rest there. This is, after all, fanfiction, and of the two stories, people are welcome to read either, both, or neither as they prefer. :)

I'm sorry if this is all a bit long-winded! Although it was an honest mistake, I felt I needed to respond publicly to such an accusation.

~Ardil the Traveller~

Hmm...that's weird, this looks to similar "Tail's Gift" by Mew3692002 to be natural, infact, a lot of stuff seems to just be copy and pasted...I'm not saying anything, maeybe I'm missing somethiing, but...yeah...

*sob*
I don't even want to think how Sonic's face looked after Shadow said that.

...

...
...
...
...
...
...
...

...
...

It was all a hallucination?

AW! And this was so beautiful, too!

reincarnation is a sad prosses

shadow should have just shut his trap and let sonic enjoy his fantasy.

this. is so sad...

seriously, i think there´s just so much CRUELTY in creating such a cheerful atmosphere and then letting it all crumble to pieces, shattering a reader´s smile...is it fun writing such stuff? :)

Jesus! I so wasn't expecting that... I can't believe I'm only reading this now... xDD

Lol, I was sort of happy for a minute that Tails was reincarnated, and then... *sigh*

This was very well written though, nice job!

I only have one word to discribe this. Awesome.

Wow...im SO good at writing reviews aren't I?

Anyways, great job! Very emotional. Keep up the good work!

Don't mind kilatails...she's(or he's) just jealous of your remarkable talent. That, or she's(he's) just a spoiled little brat who took the time to be mean to you...or both...

HOW COULD YOU?!? THIS IS SO SAD.. I WAS ACTUALLY CRYING OF HAPPINESS BECAUSE TAILS GOT REINCARNATED AND SONIC WAS HAPPY!
I ACTUALLY STARTED CRYING!-LITERALLY- YOUR SO MEAN MAKING POOR SONIC BELIEVE THAT HES REAL FRIEND IS BACK! IM NEVER READING YOUR STORIES AGAIN!

Your story was so good! I can't believe I didn't read it sooner. And the ending, was great! You are a great author.

this may sound stupid, but i'm just now reading this! and i love it so much!! i KNEW Shadow was going to say that!! (+1 in my favs!)

Whoa... that was truly amazing... especially the end.

Simply put, this is awesome.