Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: So Small A Thing - Page 1 of 2
Sameera77
2009-06-10 . chapter 1
I don't like this story. I don't mind slash stories, but I don't like the idea of Boromir raping and maltreating Pippin.
EdorasLass
2005-01-16 . chapter 1
I read this story on Tuesday, and my skin is still crawling, and yes, that is a compliment.

Very disturbing.
Culumacilinte
2004-08-26 . chapter 1
Wow... that is so... haunting... I love Boromir as well- I hate it when people think he's an evil guy- he's not, just misguided, but that was a rely good reflection of what it might have been like had he taken the Ring.. *shivers* poor Faramir...
Macotee
2004-07-23 . chapter 1
...wow... that was sad... good, but sad. great job though
Lucid Hollow
2004-01-17 . chapter 1
wow this is an excellent story. i enjoyed reading every bit of it. such a great and powerful insight to what might have happen. this is very well wriiten and i commend you for that. i loved the darkness and malevolence of the story has opposed to a happy one. well done! :):):)
Aislynn Crowdaughter
2004-01-07 . chapter 1
Hi! This is stunning. Complete, utter horror, but very stunning, and very, very dark. Greatly done!
Aislynn
Ethriel
2003-11-23 . chapter 1
wow, so dark, but realy good, my poor babys *hugs aragorn and legolas protectivly* they were skinned wah!;-;
Raphael
2003-11-04 . chapter 1
FANTASTIC. Also the single most depressing fic I've ever read, but still fantastic. Well-written, VERY interesting plot choice, everything really good! Only weakness was the fourth-to-last paragraph, telling who had died and why. It seemed a bit, cliche. That kinda paragraph, that style of telling what happened, I've seen done many times. If you could change that, this fic would be *PERFECT*! (It's already so close...)
pippin da great
2003-08-16 . chapter 1
Wow
athena
2003-04-30 . chapter 1
i know this isn't really a longish story, but do you think you could provide an update for what happened as boromir was taking over? and what happens to pippin now?
the story was well written and touching
Poor Pippin!
thank you for an excellant story
Uruloke Deathstalker
2003-02-22 . chapter 1
Brilliant.
Judas
2003-01-25 . chapter 1
...Wow. Utterly and completely disturbing, yet a terribly enjoyable read. *grin* Really makes a person glad that Boromir didn't get the ring... ^^;;

Ahh... the skins thing... very disturbing little detail....
KBriefs
2003-01-14 . chapter 1
Oooo, what a great story.... Very dark and sad.. Might there be a prequel or sequel in the works? I'd love to see what happened to the other characters, and what eventually happens to Pippin...

Keep up the good work! :)

2003-01-05 . chapter 1
(Rocks back and forth, hugging knees) So dark, so disturbing, so dark, so disturbing...
No that was actually very well written. I also like Boromir, so you get the award for what is probably the single most frightening fic I have ever read. I hope I never read another so dark, but seriously, good job. Especially the skins **shudder**
Lady Jay Grey
2002-12-29 . chapter 1
Dark AND angsty!

Love it!

Finally some Boromir/Pippin!

Evil out,

Lady Jay Grey
Return to Top