Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Case of Identity - Page 1 of 3
Oustiti
2007-08-05 . chapter 1
Dumbledore sees a corps -> "ow dear!" XD
Sirius is really funny in this one. I love the Sirius-Snap fights.
Chess
2003-10-07 . chapter 2
All right, now I'm annoyed. I could have SWORN I reviewed this! Oh well... I really love the banter between Snape and Sirius, and I'm really scared for the whole school. Oh, got to go. Update! (:
Dani
2003-08-23 . chapter 2
You must post more! And if you aren't busy, You must email when you have it finished! This is the greatest! I haven't read something this good in a really long time. The detail is great, and I'm actually quite afraid for the school! More!
kelek
2003-07-17 . chapter 2
Your story's so good! ^_^ Wow, you actually use pretty good English, too! No offense, of course! I meant, compared to how some other people write their fan fictions! So interesting! [Wondering what's going to happen next...]
herringprincess
2003-06-09 . chapter 2
thats one powerful little brew!
im afraid i wont be able to solve anything, or get the holmes references, being totally ignorant of murder mysteries generally. i do have what my dad calls 'police instinct' in that people i dont like in plays and books and things usually turn out to be baddies... but that probably wont help me here :-)
lol, 'you speak in riddles, git' humorous even in mystery/action/adventure.
brilliant as always, id tell you to write more soon but ive got so much more of your stuff still to read i probably wouldnt read it for ages anyway :-)
SurrealSerpent
2003-05-15 . chapter 2
Ah.. i love Sev and Siri fics (non-slash of course! @_@), and i really love this fic!! but update quicker pleasy?
Keep it up!
sevter
2003-05-03 . chapter 2
So who brewed the poison?
sevter
2003-05-03 . chapter 1
A very strange chapter...I'm surprised they can offer civil words to each other...
Ozma
2003-05-02 . chapter 2
It's wonderful to see a second chapter!! I love this fic!!

"The cat who did nothing in the morning" is a definite reference to the dog in one of the Holmes stories who didn't bark. Your use of Mrs. Norris was brilliant! Now you've got me wondering why she didn't react to anything unusual.

(Filch would certainly agree that Mrs. Norris is smarter than he is.)

The two really undectable poisons are horrific, and they are both brilliant inventions. You are a genius!

Speaking of genius, I love the way that you write Sirius and Severus together. ("Martyred Mongrel!" Snape's names for Sirius crack me up!)
frozen-curious
2003-04-28 . chapter 2
good to see you updated

teribe, isn't it, having such a potion exsists

(look very alike to a certain type of virus spreading...*sign*)
sweetnessspy
2003-04-24 . chapter 2
my fav stories are when sirius and snape work together and this one also has a damn good plot- please post more soon! i wanna read more
negative9
2003-04-23 . chapter 2
*DUN DUN DUN...* That was great! I love how Snape's trying to be professional about everything, and Black keeps interrupting with stupid/humourous comments. You're wonderful at writing Snape's thoughts, I can't wait to read more!
ickle-helena
2003-04-23 . chapter 2
Great! Fabulous lines as usual: "You speak in riddles, git." Makes perfect sense that Snape knows a lot about murder weapons. The undetectable poisons sound very interesting as well, original and plausible.

Snape wants to be wrong? Must be bad...
chris
2003-04-17 . chapter 2
hello
sorry for my bad english because I'm french !
I love you fic ^^ I like so much the couple Sirius and Severus ^^

I'm waiting for the next chapter!
See you soon,,
kitsunelover
2003-04-13 . chapter 2
OOh . . . this is really good! Keep going, but don't let Snape die! Other than that . . . um . . . well, just keep writing! *continues biting fingernails in agitation*
Return to Top