Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: A Case of Identity - Page 3 of 3
Saphy 9/19/02 . chapter 1
Bwahahaha, I love this! Sirius and Snape are wonderfully hilarious _

Write on!
Kaminarikodomo 9/16/02 . chapter 1
Sirius and Severus investigating a crime together? I don't know which one I pity more...:) Keep up the good work! Oh, by the way - are Severus and Minerva *ever* going to escape from the Mont-Streppings, hint...hint...
frozen-curious 9/16/02 . chapter 1
hello

guess who i am

it is *me*

someone ask you to update the when in rome story

a very interesting story by the way

so pls uddate soon
nsngrl 9/15/02 . chapter 1
Hmmm...it starts out springly (my gwad, is that a word?)-little light humor, love the verbal pokings between Sev and Sirius. Mental picture of Albus looking down upon the corpse, going, "oh, dear." *cackle*

But then, reality comes to forefront-the deceased wasn't there for a cup of tea w/ Sev, but more likely to kill him. What a depressing thought, Sev being aware of his limited time left to live.

Any chance at spilling the beans on Sirius getting murderous on Malfoy? pretty please?

One little inconsistency-at beginning of story, about 15 lines down when Sirius says something about a "soulless wonder" and Sev retorts "...you say that as though it's a good thing." Shoudnl't that line read "...as though it's a *bad* thing"?

Keep the chpts coming. You can't dangle a mystery like this and just abandon it! LOL.

p.s. just make sure Sev is breathing still. May I be biased, (fell rather hard over Alan Rickman, mind you) but Snape has to be my fav, Death Eater or no Death Eater.
Clio 9/15/02 . chapter 1
Another great story, but update 'When in Rome', UPDATE 'WHEN IN ROME', UPDATE UPDATE...

Ahem, well, I digress.

I agree with you that Rickman would make a terrific Sherlock Holmes, even better than Snape, but this surely is a matter of taste.

I like very much how you have Snape and Sirius bickering in this story.
S 9/15/02 . chapter 1
Loved that! The banter between Snape and Black was great fun to read, and I love whodunnits. Oh please, please continue...
Ozma 9/15/02 . chapter 1
Brilliant! Brilliant! Severus and Sirius together had me rolling on the floor in hysterics! I LOVE the way they trade barbs and insults, and their subtly portrayed mutual respect for each other!

Minerva is wonderfully captured as always. Easily a match for her two bad boys. And Dumbledore is a delight. I can't wait to see Hermione's roll in this story too, she's clever and sharp enough to hold her own in this company!

More! Please!
Spark-Chick 9/15/02 . chapter 1
Ooooh, I love this! This is soooooo cool! I demand more soon! Now I beg for more soon! Now I threaten you with my Snape clones! Mwahahahaaaaa! Anyway, it's quite good. More soon, please?
38 found: « Prev Page 1 .. 3
Return to Top