|Reviews for The Crime of Master Samwise|
| Morris the Fool 7/29/06 . chapter 1
That is what I call a good fic!
| rabidsamfan 2/15/04 . chapter 1
I'd like to see where you'd go with this, but it works fine as a standalone. I like Sam realizing what he's going to have to do, and Frodo getting schizophrenic.
| Iorhael 2/9/04 . chapter 1
I was such a lazybone. I read but I never reviewed. But it has long changed. I now read and review. But I cannot believe I've never reviewed your stories which I have read in years past and loved them immensely. Including this. And I might be one of the many people who will weep when you decide not to post here anymore.
| Billabong680 1/17/04 . chapter 1
I think that you can put a new chapter... please
| ShireElf 4/18/03 . chapter 1
AH! EVIL CLIFFHANGER! WRITE MORE!
| Lindiniel 4/6/03 . chapter 1
great story. I once thought of writing about what would happen if Sam killed Gollum, but I never wrote it. Well done.
PS I agree with what you said about slash fiction - I'm not homophobic (how can I be? I'm bisexual myself.) but it's a shame if two people can't love each other without sex being involved. It's not what the late great Tolkien would have wanted.
| TheSilentScribe 3/31/03 . chapter 1
that was awsome. i really think you should keep going with this one. i enjoyed very much, you described the characters so well, i could actually see Frodo and Sam hanging from the edge of Mount Doom. i thought that you brought on the Gollum personality in Frodo a little too early. but otherwise, that was great! keep going it was much promise.
ttyl Peace Out
| Acadienne 3/21/03 . chapter 1
THis was so freakin' good! You really showed Frodo's madness really really well! actually quite terrifying and I love how you have him deciding b/t Sam or the Ring, really brilliant! great climax to the story!:) you can end it here and i'll be fine or you can continue and i'll still be fine _'' either way is good :) keep up the great work!
| Elbereth 2/7/03 . chapter 1
*wide-eyed* More...? Please?
Seriously, though, I think this is fitting by itself, but if you wrote a continuation I would read it in a heartbeat.
| wanequelle 1/25/03 . chapter 1
That was a good ending but one thing I thought you should have done is, in the book it said that when Frodo put on the ring Sauron was alerted and set all his power on the mountain so I thought at least some Nazgul should have been there or something like that. Very good! I'm glad Frodo didn't have to lose a finger but he died? Well I think he did, it didn't say for sure but... Oh well I think that should be the end. But what do I know?
| Smeagol 11/5/02 . chapter 1
Poor Gollum! That story made cry, it was so beautiful. Do you really think Frodo would have saved Sam? That was so beautiful!
| yukinasan 11/2/02 . chapter 1
NOOOOOOOOOOO PLEASE DON'T END IT THERE IT CAN'T BE OVER. whas gonna happen? i REALLY hope you decide to continue it. great job. ill put this on my fave list. o and if i can find out how to delete a account ill change my name to QTpie_pippinsgurl. if neone knows how to delete one tell me in a review. ill be really thankful
| amc623 10/6/02 . chapter 1
Oh wow! What a powerful story! I've been reading through several of your stories lately (though i haven't reviewed them all) and you are an amazing writer! it's amazing what kind of powerful emotions you can display so clearly in your stories!
About the ending for this one-i'm really not sure. I would like more, but then again this was a pretty good ending too. I guess it just depends on where you want to go with it.
Thank you for all your wonderful stories!
| chibi neko 9/30/02 . chapter 1
Oh, how I loved this story too! (you are SO the hotness!) I liked how Frodo reffered to Sam as a creature even though it wasn't written dialouge. Your discripitions are supurb. I would tell ya more of what I liked but I have about 1 minute to go on this computer (I'm at the library) soooo...Peace Out! -
PS I LUV YOU!
| Timber1 9/23/02 . chapter 1
Great Story! I agree it needs more, though...