Reviews for The Tale of an Orc

Reviews For: The Tale of an Orc - Reviews: Page 1 of 5

FireChildSlytherin5 2007-04-03 ch 12,	abuseVery instresting story and plot so far. Liked it.
SimplyChristine 2005-12-28 ch 12,	abuseWOW! Keep writing! Man, I just love these fics...I've always felt sorry for the orcs that used to be elves
Silverscale 2004-07-08 ch 12,	abuseA wonderful fic keep it up.
Allyrien Chantel de Montrev... 2003-12-05 ch 12,	abuseeek! but I'm glad you updated it!
Adara of Middle Earth 2003-11-23 ch 12,	abuseThanks for updating this. I like a story where an orc is capable of being redeemed. I hope he escapes Morgoth's eye.
Soledad 2003-11-18 ch 12, anon.	abuseI'm glad you found the time to update. This is a unique story, both by perspective and by its main hero. Here's to hope that ff.net allows me to review this time. crosses fingers
GoL 2003-11-18 ch 1, anon.	abuseA sheer form of literary magnificence executed to almost Tolkien-likeness. Great job! Instead of devoting this fan fic to the revered elves, a delicate 'tribute' is paid to the Orcs, who are often discriminated against. Provides another perspective of viewing these grotesque creatures, and a brilliant job done at that! This reviewer is not exactly a seasoned critique, so she knows not how to proceed. All I can say is, keep up the good work, Casey! Looking forward to more suprises from ya! =D
jilian baade 2003-11-17 ch 12,	abuseCasey, this is getting better. Of all the Noldor, Finrod is one of two I can believe would be able to veil the Orc. The other is Maglor, of course. You know, I went looking for this the other day, and I'm so pleased to see you have updated; I was starting to think you might have abandoned it.
Sunsetcheetah 2003-11-17 ch 12,	abuseYOU'RE ALIVE!! hugs And yet again another great chapter! I can also tell you I know how you feel with all those projects your dealing with cuz now that I'm a freshmen in college, it's the same! I haven't gotten around to typing out anything for my story but anyway enough about my story. Again I loved it! Keep it up! Check ya later CAtz!
RavieChan 2003-07-29 ch 11,	abuseWow... that was really beautiful. I love it. I'm hooked.
Jillian Baade 2003-06-19 ch 11, anon.	abuseI would LOVE to know who the Orc once was. Finrod certainly has his own ideas, I guess you'll tell us soon enough!
Belthronding 2003-05-24 ch 11, anon.	abuseAhh, I didn't see this had been updated... It's such a beautiful tale. You've woven sadness with kindness with such feeling. =)
Mr Popo rocks 2003-05-10 ch 11,	abuseclaps i'm so glad i found this fic! i was just wondering through looking at moonstones updates and i clicked on her fav stories thingy and i found this! and it's brilliant! so you need to update soon cos now i'm all interested and want more and more chaps! :D
Sunsetcheetah 2003-04-30 ch 11,	abuseAwesome!! Totally awesome!! I can't wait for your next chapter and I think it'll be just as great as the rest. Unfortunetly (spelling?) I can't write any more cuz the bell for the next class is going to ring any sec... Keep up the great work!! And thanks again!! And I will keep bugging you for every excellent chapter! Check ya later CAtz!!
Adara of Middle Earth 2003-04-26 ch 2,	abuseI read the entire 11 chapters and was hooked by the story. I like the simple writing style you chose for this story; the tight sentences which are also short for good dramatic effect. I even kinda like your orc.

Return to Top