Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: I'm not lost, are you? - Page 1 of 2
wolfsbabe midnight
2007-05-07 . chapter 8
oh that was a nice ending. :)
wolfsbabe midnight
2007-05-07 . chapter 3
oh god! even a few years later this chapter is still damned funny! Especially with Gimli running into the walls. My eyes were tearing. We time to reread the other chapters. Might even go back and read the other two we wrote.

~wolfsbabe midnight (formerly babmidnight)~
Thrillzone
2004-01-19 . chapter 8
LOL! ^-^ That was great!
Lady Tsuru
2003-07-23 . chapter 8
Loved it, loved it, loved it!
Nessa Ar-Feiniel
2003-03-27 . chapter 8
I love this story.
Ole 4 Clay
2003-03-25 . chapter 8
this is a great story! but i don't know why u rated it PG-13. everything is HILARIOUS! please write a sequel! PLEASE! =)

Greenleafgrl~
Ringwraith9
2003-03-19 . chapter 1
Your writing is good and the characters are acting Tolkienish but maybe it would fit better in action adventure.
Nimeneth
2003-03-09 . chapter 8
im a new reviewer, but not a new reader. its Marissa. and i love this chapter! its really good. and a good ending, i have to say. i love the meeting up with the dwarves. and the story was funny! Namarie!!
Mother Nature
2002-11-19 . chapter 2
Now, you dont mind constructive criticism from a fellow writer do you? I hope not cause here i go -

Hate to be a nag, but i must say that your characterizations of Legolas and Gimli (That is G-I-M-L-I) are a little off. They talk in the old english style usually and i know that Legolas doesnt put "Hey" at the beginning of as many sentences as you have him do. Also, Legolas hates caves, and he probably wouldnt be helping Gimli explore as much as he is, he also probably wouldnt add as much insult to injury (they hypothetical type of course) as he is.

But those are just my own views and interpretations of their characters.

Anyhoo, all in all, i really like this story so far. The plot is intriguing and your style is new, i like new.

This is getting long so i'll spare all other pleasentries and just say: Congratulations on a great fic.

See you around! ^.^


Mother Nature the Mother of Earth
Kila, Queen of the Smurfs
2002-10-20 . chapter 7
cool. ;-)
Niko1
2002-10-20 . chapter 6
Review for you: Whee! Funfun! Write more! :) i need sleep.
~Niko
Ithildin
2002-10-18 . chapter 6
i like i laughed i want MORE
Fae Touched
2002-10-11 . chapter 3
*laughs insanely* Right into a wall! Bwuahahaha! Just like me with broken glasses earlier today. Ahem.

Anyway, this is great. It's so rare that you come across a decently written humour story (in this section).
heather
2002-10-11 . chapter 3
Very Good! I'm looking forward to the next chapter.
ola
2002-10-11 . chapter 3
lol, funny funny =) but their friendship doesn't seen all that friendly.... please writ more!
Return to Top