| Author |
Post |
 |
otherrealmwriterLet's see how long can those parasites and vermins keep this little doggie alive. And fortunately, she haven't blocked me yet!! HUZZAH! I left another jewel for her to sniff on, see what kind of response will I get? ;) Wow. O_O I send a nice review and get blocked but you Rozen, the Ruler of Ripping Apart Fanbrats here didn't Irony don'tcha think? Feb 10th 2009, 5:39pm #201 |
 |
Air ConditionHeh, I'm not blocked either! Feb 10th 2009, 5:40pm #202 |
 |
otherrealmwriterMeh. Tis be why I use Anonyomus reviews. She is starting to be like My Immortal in a way except with no chatspeak and Mary-Sue Feb 10th 2009, 5:47pm #203 |
 |
Air ConditionShe is starting to be like My Immortal in a way except with no chatspeak and Mary-Sue Well I'm not sure I'd compare it to THAT. My Immortal was much worse. How do you see the comparison? And I just realized that My Immortal got taken off of FF.net... Damn. Feb 10th 2009, 5:49pm #204 |
 |
sakuuyaIt's been gone for a while. Unfortunately. MI was funnier. This story hasn't gotten into So Bad It's Awesome territory, at least for me. Plus, MI's authoress kept calling her flamers "preps" like it was the worst insult in the world. This chick is much less creative in her stupidity. Feb 10th 2009, 5:51pm #205 |
 |
Zanralotta*sighs* Fine! I want to see this trainwreck myself... Can anyone send my a PM with the story link? That being said, I'd think that if this fanbrat doesn't get it after multiple people trying to reason with her, she's beyond hope. Isn't this horse already beaten to death and has become an enormous waste of time? There are a lot of people who'd appreciate concrit... not that this episode isn't funny like hell. In 5 years she'll probably remember, flinch and wonder, "what were I thinking?" Feb 10th 2009, 6:00pm #206 |
 |
jafarjasmineforever2005I got blocked! Feb 10th 2009, 6:20pm #207 |
 |
RozenI got blocked! OMGWTFBBQ?! I am super-surprised I am still not blocked, EVEN NOW!!! :OOOO Anyway, let's see how Zan handle her. ;) (Just sent him the link) Feb 10th 2009, 6:24pm #208 |
 |
Rozen*edited for post below* Feb 10th 2009, 6:27pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:05pm #209 |
 |
ZanralottaOMGWTFBBQ?! I am super-surprised I am still not blocked, EVEN NOW!!! :OOOO Anyway, let's see how Zan handle her. ;) (Just sent him the link) *cough* I'm a she. And I don't really want to handle this specific fanbrat. I've much better stuff to do with my time. I just want to enjoy the show... Feb 10th 2009, 6:28pm #210 |
 |
RozenI'm a she. And I don't really want to handle this specific fanbrat. I've much better stuff to do with my time. I just want to enjoy the show... Right... =x Well, let's see what that vermin wants to bitch about my flame. ;P Taken from previous post: Well, well, this is an unexpected comeback from one of her parasites: ROZEN'S URGENT SPORK ON VERMIN! MEGA-SURPRISE AWESOME!! you comment on beyond the mask is not worth anything in fact you are the S H I T H E A D HOLEH CRAP, REALLY? And what makes you think your response is worth anything since you can't spell and capitalize shit? ;D. Want to know why because you are reading something that you don't like and can not stand others do And you probably haven't realize that I am given perfect rights to read whatever the fuck I want, let it be whether I like it or not, dumbfuck! =D. If you are that jealous then write a better story but then many people still will not read it because you as a person suck That's not my purpose of this account. I flame, dimwit. And if I flame, why should I be bothered to be called a meanie or a sucky person like you vermin claimed me to be? And jealous? It's not jealously you see in me. It's insight and unwavering confidence of judging a story and a person. FUCKHEAD. Or would you like a nickname too? the idiot is you if your only purpose is to flame people NO SHIT SHERLOCK! I am a flamer, duh!. In fact i pity you since you have nothing else better to do with your life And does that mean you have anything better to do in your life yourself? I think you just wasted some of it by responding to me with pointless drabble. I am not a lackey because i like reading a story. Yes, and as if any 8 years old is going to give a flying fuck about that piece of diarrhea By the way i never said you could not read anything you want but why read something you hate? It's so hateful I find it funny so you got any problem with my twist of nature? Too bad for you. ;P you have all my pity i hope you get a life soon And you have all my pity for losing all your lives by responding to me with more hatred. i never said you had to like it but why read it if you don't seem like something only an idiot would do I think the answer is pret-ty obvious. ;). But why flame it say you piece and move on not keep reading and saying disgusting comment because the story is not the way you like it If it meets my criteria of flame-worthy, I flame however the fuck I want because it's my right AND my purpose for this account. ;D. If you think it could be better write your own version and prove it. Only a hypocrite will do that, I am way to immaculate a flamer to drown myself into that part of ego. ;D Feb 10th 2009, 6:38pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:29pm #211 |
 |
RozenC-C-C-C-C-CHAIN SPORK ON AUTHOR AFTER READER!!! I would delete this before you get your ass kicked off the site, you broke every rule What rule do I break? :D And what you mean by delete? Your story or the reviews? If you mean either one, it will serve my purpose...it's...AWESOME!!! :D. You have no right to go after me like this. Wrong. I have every perfect right to tear you limb from limb through word chains. ;D Feb 10th 2009, 7:32pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:33pm #212 |
 |
otherrealmwriterBy the way i never said you could not read anything you want but why read something you hate? Why do kids today not capitalize I in the way she used it? Want to know why because you are reading something that you don't like and can not stand others doIf you are that jealous then write a better story but then many people still will not read it because you as a person suck God that's a runon. _-_ I am not a lackey because i like reading a story God why do people only capitalize the first letter of a sentence and nothing else? If you want to revenge flame someone, at least use decent grammar. EDIT: C-C-C-C-C-CHAIN SPORK ON AUTHOR AFTER READER!!! I would delete this before you get your ass kicked off the site, you broke every rule What rule do I break? :D And what you mean by delete? Your story or the reviews? If you mean either one, it will serve my purpose...it's...AWESOME!!! :D. You have no right to go after me like this. Wrong. I have every perfect right to tear you limb from limb through word chains. ;D God kids today think everything should be handed to them. Well News flash it ain't gonna be. Suck it the fuck up! I had to and I am only 18.75 so I am near her age. Feb 10th 2009, 7:33pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:36pm #213 |
 |
Wesfanemt333Yeah, she's a real winner, that one. :) Feb 10th 2009, 7:35pm #214 |
 |
RozenULTRA CHAIN SPORK-SPORK-BANG-BANG!! WHOOPIE~! Author says: look at the rules about language, reviews can not consist of profane language and abuse. Shithead, fuck, maggot, lapdog.......you think those are constructive criticism? Who said I am being constructive? Dipshit. ;P And you seemed to fail to understand that cussing can be filtered, don't you? TOS never stopped us from cussing, if it do, F/R would be long gone before we even came here. Look up the word. N0 thx :) Fangirl says: I never said i was a great speller and i don't plan to be so what You are proud of it, I am sure you are :) 'Why the hell would I write a story in a flame-purpose account? That's the most hypocritical thing a flamer can do.' My god you a hypocrite since you do have a story on your account. So what do you care if i do write to flamers but to tell you the true your the one of the first i have pm before and the only reason is because your so stupid and funny Funny thing is, you're the one being funny here since you have huge run on with no capitalize or grammar or spell shit whatsoever. ;). This site is for for who cares about mistakes No, it's for those who love bashing hopeless author as well. Also no you don't have a life because all your doing is flaming and no i don't have a story up because i do not like to put my this one this site Good excuse, coming from someone who never looked into my life before. I am pretty sure I did a lot better job at having a life than you who waste all your time responding to me.. My stories are for mature reader but you are not one so sorry. Right, if you do let me read it, I'll be sure to contribute it to my dog to bite it to shreds. Read what you want hate what you want and be a hypocrite all your life NO U. because those definitions are all opposite and it's directed back to you of how you behaved. If i am losing life by responding so are you and more so since you get joy by just having response. Of course, but you lose more since you keep getting torn to shreds. Also i would like to know how am i hypocrite? I don't think a hypocrite deserve to know what that word means due to your astounding clueless-ness. Feb 10th 2009, 7:40pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:47pm #215 |
 |
otherrealmwriterShithead, fuck, maggot, lapdog First two are cuss but who calls maggot (a baby fly) and lapdog (a small dog or overzelous servant who does whatever the master says to please them) are not Fangirl says: I never said i was a great speller and i don't plan to be so what 'Why the hell would I write a story in a flame-purpose account? That's the most hypocritical thing a flamer can do.' My god you a hypocrite since you do have a story on your account. So what do you care if i do write to flamers but to tell you the true your the one of the first i have pm before and the only reason is because your so stupid and funny. This site is for for who cares about mistakes. Also no you don't have a life because all your doing is flaming and no i don't have a story up because i do not like to put my this one this site. My stories are for mature reader but you are not one so sorry. Read what you want hate what you want and be a hypocrite all your life. If i am losing life by responding so are you and more so since you get joy by just having response. Also i would like to know how am i hypocrite? God I would have loved to see them go toe to toe with FR! XD Feb 10th 2009, 7:44pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:45pm #216 |
 |
RozenSporking-spree...ending!! *Hoah!!!* God I would have loved to see them go toe to toe with FR! XD Well, thankfully they don't have to. It's kind of a letdown though. :/ Feb 10th 2009, 7:50pm #217 |
 |
RozenSPORKING-RE-CHAIN!!! Author says: Can't write, preach? can you? BITCH? I love you kind of reviewers, that or you do write but are so embarassed by what you produc and know those who you flame would flame back at your crap you publish it under another name. As if I am truly going to post anything here just for you to get your revenge. ;) Come to me when you have the balls to actually write. I write and I draw and I am willing to take criticisms to heart, as for you, you are a poor display of an ugly writer with no hope of redemption. I win. ;) Fangirl says: i am not going to this forum just for you and your friends enjoyment if you want you friends to see what i have said you can post it in you own forum I just did. And you admitted your defeat. I glad to see that you know that you are whining. ORLY? Who is the one that posted the first comment behind my flaming? Hmm? And I am glad you admitted your quick defeat by disabling the PM feature. Nice work, bro. Feb 10th 2009, 7:55pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 7:59pm #218 |
 |
Dreamera TearWho exactly is it that's gotten you so riled up? Link, please? Feb 10th 2009, 8:00pm #219 |
 |
jafarjasmineforever2005Yeah I"d like a link too plz. Feb 10th 2009, 8:01pm #220 |
 |
RozenI think you both know who the author is. As for the fangirl, she's lost by disabling the PM feature...so, too bad, ;) Feb 10th 2009, 8:02pm #221 |
 |
Dreamera TearWhat a total sore loser. Feb 10th 2009, 8:05pm #222 |
 |
Rozen10 ++ COMBO SPORK CHAIN!! SSSTYLISH!!! S------MOKIN'!! Feb 10th 2009, 8:07pm #223 |
 |
Eleve OsirianI left her my opinions, and she blocked me. Surprisingly, her reply wasn't as harsh as the ones I've read above: I deleted the review alert afer two sentences, have blocked you and you can go burn in flamers hell. You have no respect for author so you don't reserv any.You find one sentence in any story with grammar like this liek dis cuz peple aren't niece I dare you. Because it does not exist. And you know what you say I am whiny because I have 600plus reviews, I'd rather have 6 then listen to you. I am not one of those weak ** writers who only writ for reviews to flame their egoI guess I just dont 'reserv' reviews...how that had anything to do with her story is beyond me. xD I actually find this person quite amusing. I'd like to imagine that she is young, but who knows? Feb 10th 2009, 8:30pm #224 |
 |
RozenI guess I just dont 'reserv' reviews...how that had anything to do with her story is beyond me. xD I actually find this person quite amusing. I'd like to imagine that she is young, but who knows? W00T! Probably because she's abused in the past and want to act tough? Who knows? hahaha , ha :D I am thankful though that I am not the only one who find this kittie amusing. Feb 10th 2009, 8:35pm #225 |
 |
Eleve OsirianHas she blocked you yet? I sent her a PM before she blocked me that was probably more friendlier than it should've been....I don't think she can handle any sort of feedback to be honest. At least she took down her author's note! xD Feb 10th 2009, 8:37pm #226 |
 |
RozenI've been blocked after going through a straight 10 combo spork on response of her and her fangirl ;P But these blocks strengthen my resolve. MUAHAHAH!! *will stop spamming now* Feb 10th 2009, 8:38pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 8:39pm #227 |
 |
sakuuya"You find one sentence in any story with grammar like this liek dis cuz peple aren't niece I dare you. Because it does not exist." Is she challenging us to find grammar that sucks as bad as hers, or sentences better than she can write?Feb 10th 2009, 8:38pm #228 |
 |
jafarjasmineforever2005I was blocked after 2 reviews and she sent me 2 revenge flames. Didn't even bother replying just keep em there for entertainment. Feb 10th 2009, 8:40pm #229 |
 |
Eleve OsirianLol in some strange, sick way, I would laugh at a revenge review from her. I got one from a twilight author who couldn't handle concrit, and it's made me laugh everytime I look at it. Feb 10th 2009, 8:52pm #230 |
 |
Dreamera TearHi Kiaga, I thought your review for her was very nice. She's just an immature brat who clearly isn't gonna be able to make it out in the real world unless she cleans her act up. You certainly don't merit the review reply you got. She's a manipulative person, and we shouldn't get ourselves so worked up over her. It probably just makes her more excited since she can throw 600++ reviewers into the face of other flamers. And her brain is probably too small to comprehend the fact that there could be more than one person who doesn't like her fic. That's probably why she thinks all of us are just one single person. Feb 10th 2009, 9:36pm #231 |
 |
Eleve OsirianHalf of her reviews are by flamers, or by stupid people saying to ignore the concrit. Why don't they get it? While I agree that some of the reviews went a bit overboard, it's stupid that all these people think she is this great writer....I wonder what they would think if they knew how much of a bitch she could be. The only reason she allows them to review is because they kiss her ass and tell her her writing is flawless. I can definitely say these people have inflated her ego to the point of no return... I have to laugh at some of them: Sure there are grammar errors but thats to be expected given that you are not a professional. LOL. I didn't know someone needed to be a "professional" at using the english language...that's a new one. don't let the reviewers get you down I have the same problems with grammer and sentence structure and all that stuff and I don't let them get to me. writing, especially on a site like this, is for enjoyment and improventment and it doesn't need to be perfect just written well as yours is righhhhtttt....... And if they aren't dismissing concrit, they are simply reviewing like this: love story. pleze update soon/, , lj b jmh gbvb gh h hj gh guhkjlkvhyb jn vyghujnk yghujkl gyuhjk guhhuyghijkhghuijkjhgctfguhijko jhgvcx4ec5gy huijkolij hbugytfgy hkjmljhuydfyguhijihgf6d54 yup. There is your answer folks...there is no point in reviewing her story, because it will just make her ego even bigger. Feb 10th 2009, 10:10pm . Edited Feb 10th 2009, 10:11pm #232 |
 |
eliskaDude, you guys all suck. I never got a reply to mine D:~ Feb 11th 2009, 3:10am #233 |
 |
Vesper CoreShe's just an immature brat who clearly isn't gonna be able to make it out in the real world unless she cleans her act up. You certainly don't merit the review reply you got. She's a manipulative person, and we shouldn't get ourselves so worked up over her. It probably just makes her more excited since she can throw 600++ reviewers into the face of other flamers. And her brain is probably too small to comprehend the fact that there could be more than one person who doesn't like her fic. That's probably why she thinks all of us are just one single person. Quoted for truth. She just too damn narrow-minded. I'm half-tempted to dish out some more criticism using my sock, as she's blocked me. Well, if I'm in the mood, I guess. ;) She still hasn't acknowledged the existence of punctuation marks in her latest chapter. Why am I not surprised? The only reason she allows them to review is because they kiss her ass and tell her her writing is flawless. I can definitely say these people have inflated her ego to the point of no return. Yep, and she goes all berserk and incomprehensible to us bubble bursters, lashing out anger-induced drivel that's practically equivalent to lulz. Dude, you guys all suck. I never got a reply to mine D:~ You just missed half of your life, Beth. ;) Feb 11th 2009, 4:22am #234 |
 |
eliskaYou just missed half of your life, Beth. ;) T.T. -sits in a corner and draws circles on the floor- Feb 11th 2009, 4:24am #235 |
 |
Dreamera TearDon't be sad Beth *hugs* anyway, her review replies aren't that amusing anymore. She's decided to be as stubborn as a mule. I mean, brownie points for that, but take them all away for not listening to good advice, and for being a stuck up prick! Feb 11th 2009, 4:26am #236 |
 |
RozenLet's just consider herself OWNED by us and DISPOSED by us as a lost product. ;) I am happy enough just to commemorate the fact that thanks to her and her useless parasites (Fangirls), I scored a Super 10 Combo Spork in a row. I hope I contribute enough for WoW thread today as a honorable member of FPA. ;) Feb 11th 2009, 4:29am . Edited Feb 11th 2009, 4:30am #237 |
 |
Miss LeanneI know I'm late coming into the game, but may I have a link to this atrocity being spoken of? If I feel so led, I might leave a review, but at this point I just want to watch the game. :-) Feb 11th 2009, 7:30am #238 |
 |
Dreamera TearI don't think we should be giving her anymore ammo for now... Let her boost her own ego, it'll only make her fall even harder in the future. But I can PM you the review page. Have fun reading through it. Feb 11th 2009, 7:40am #239 |
 |
otherrealmwriterI deleted the review alert afer two sentences, have blocked you and you can go burn in flamers hell. You have no respect for author so you don't reserv any.You find one sentence in any story with grammar like this liek dis cuz peple aren't niece I dare you. Because it does not exist. And you know what you say I am whiny because I have 600plus reviews, I'd rather have 6 then listen to you. I am not one of those weak ** writers who only writ for reviews to flame their ego My god, she could support her "LYKZ MESA SO GOD!!!!!!!" if she could SPELL . The most reviews I got on a story was 46 T_T Lucky bitch She's just an immature brat who clearly isn't gonna be able to make it out in the real world unless she cleans her act up. You certainly don't merit the review reply you got. She's a manipulative person, and we shouldn't get ourselves so worked up over her. It probably just makes her more excited since she can throw 600++ reviewers into the face of other flamers. And her brain is probably too small to comprehend the fact that there could be more than one person who doesn't like her fic. That's probably why she thinks all of us are just one single person. I am going to love to see her in college: "This story is crap. You got a F"~ Professor "LYKZ ZOMG!!!1111!!1 GO BUN IN FLAMER HELL!!11111!!! I HAV 600+ REVEIWS ON MY HP FANFCI!!!!!!!!!!11111111"~ fanbrat. "Young lady, leave my class and never return. No refunds on your tution. I will see that the dean expells you. For now you are on Achedemic Suspension"~ Professor "FUCK YOU FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK MOTHERFUCKER DIE!!!!!!!!!!111111 ZMOG UR MAEN!!!!!1" Fanbrat She ends up fired from every menal job she gets. The only reason she allows them to review is because they kiss her ass and tell her her writing is flawless. I can definitely say these people have inflated her ego to the point of no return. Like I said, she is an epic fail when she gets to college. Feb 11th 2009, 9:18am #240 |
 |
Miss LeanneNot just epic fail when she gets to college - epic fail at life. What does it take for someone to learn to take constructive criticism, whether they write or not? And thank you for the link, terriestal-angell. Feb 11th 2009, 9:36am . Edited Feb 11th 2009, 9:37am #241 |
 |
Wesfanemt333I dropped her in the Sin Bin on Can We Talk. And I sporked her shitfic on the X-Box forum. :) Feb 11th 2009, 9:37am #242 |
 |
Thranduil Oropherion ReduxAnyway, let's see how Zan handle her. ;) (Just sent him the link) You know something, Rozen? Someone who takes such offense at iffy grammar and punctuation should take care to proof posts. I'm also happy to see that you guys are carrying on Flame Rising's edict of not becoming an army of flamers. Oh -- wait! I haven't seen such a dogpile in a long time. So let me get this straight -- if someone ignores your graciously bestowed concrit you are then justified in ganging up and holding the author up to ridicule? Has any of you stopped to think that maybe this author's increasingly bad attitude is a result of the mass negative reviews and the mocking here? Only a 'few' of these reviews weren't concrit? Perhaps, but Rozen's crossed the line into personal abuse. Feb 11th 2009, 12:20pm #243 |
 |
Wesfanemt333Actually, she started having a horrible attitude well before it became a dog-pile. Even when people were very nicely giving her con-crit, she'd respond with a "Fuck Off!, Go To Hell!" Etc. Anyone who didn't give her a glowing review gets blocked. I sent her a very nice polite message, for which I received this: You have received a private message from: Name removed to protect the bratty. Go to Hell! that is all I have to say. Or kindergarten and learn if you have nothing nice to say don't say it. You think you are being polite but you're not. No matter how nice you word it when you go after someone who is begging you to please just stop hounding them bout grammar, is rude. I just want to write, nothing more, I just want to write. Leave me the god damn alone. You stupid arse holes should go and create a website for flamers and leave the rest of us alone. Do not hide your rudeness behind a polite email for if you had any respect at all you would have not sent this email. You would have respected my wishes. You are as fucking moronoc and disrespectful as the flamers. I don't flame people. I give con-crit. Feb 11th 2009, 12:26pm . Edited Feb 11th 2009, 12:27pm #244 |
 |
Thranduil Oropherion ReduxActually, she started having a horrible attitude well before it became a dog-pile. Even when people were very nicely giving her con-crit, she'd respond with a "Fuck Off!, Go To Hell!" Etc. Anyone who didn't give her a glowing review gets blocked. I sent her a very nice polite message, for which I received this: I've seen that, and I know the name of the author in question. I went to read the story, expecting a horror show of epic proportions. I must say, I've read better, but I've also read worse. When exactly did you get this reply? Before or after Rozen started calling her a pathetic S.H.I.T.H.E.A.D.? "You think you are being polite but you're not. No matter how nice you word it when you go after someone who is begging you to please just stop hounding them bout grammar, is rude. I just want to write, nothing more, I just want to write. Leave me the god damn alone." This sounds like someone who has already taken a lot of abuse and just wants to be left alone. And that's why God made back buttons. If a story is garbage and the author won't change, you just stop reading. I don't flame people. I give con-crit. I'm sure you do, but the mature attitude when someone declines your advice is to shrug, go away, and let them learn the lesson on their own. Not put them in a 'Sin Bin' or laugh about their incoherent PMs here. I read the review pages, and I can see where her attitude is coming from. Feb 11th 2009, 12:39pm #245 |
 |
Eleve OsirianI'm sure you do, but the mature attitude when someone declines your advice is to shrug, go away, and let them learn the lesson on their own. Not put them in a 'Sin Bin' or laugh about their incoherent PMs here. I read the review pages, and I can see where her attitude is coming from. I must respectfully disagree with you. Yes, I do agree that Rozen's review was a bit much, but you cannot compare all of us with her. We are all different people, with different opinions. Just because she made an attack, doesn't mean I did. I think you should stop and think about how you're grouping us before you make assumptions. The purpose of this site is to get better at writing, to enjoy writing, etc. What freedom would there be if someone starts telling me how to review? As the reviewer, that is my job to do as I see fit. And why not laugh? When someone personally attacks me or friends, I think I have that right. Give respect where respect is due..and it isn't with her. Feb 11th 2009, 12:47pm #246 |
 |
Wesfanemt333I've seen that, and I know the name of the author in question. I went to read the story, expecting a horror show of epic proportions. I must say, I've read better, but I've also read worse. When exactly did you get this reply? Before or after Rozen started calling her a pathetic S.H.I.T.H.E.A.D.? Well before Rozen jumped in. I had looked at her reviews before sending her the message. There weren't any real flames, maybe a handful of honest concrit. Nothing really harsh either. This sounds like someone who has already taken a lot of abuse and just wants to be left alone. And that's why God made back buttons. If a story is garbage and the author won't change, you just stop reading. Abuse? How is nicely being told that your grammar needs some work abuse? I can see if they were all like Rozen's reviews, but they weren't. I'm sure you do, but the mature attitude when someone declines your advice is to shrug, go away, and let them learn the lesson on their own. Not put them in a 'Sin Bin' or laugh about their incoherent PMs here. I read the review pages, and I can see where her attitude is coming from. The Sin Bin serves it's purpose. I happen to enjoy it, as do others. Your version of mature, is fine for you. I'll go about things my way, and you go about yours. Feb 11th 2009, 12:50pm #247 |
 |
Thranduil Oropherion ReduxThe purpose of this site is to get better at writing, to enjoy writing, etc. What freedom would there be if someone starts telling me how to review? Some people think this site is for the purpose of posting fanfiction -- by writers of all levels of expertise. And what freedom is there if someone starts telling you how to write? I saw as many complaints of characters being OOC as I saw complaints about grammar and spelling. Yes, grammar and spelling are important, but I don't think there's a single one of us on this site who couldn't be absolutely demolished by a writer of greater skill. I've been writing for a while now, and the chief thing I've learned is that the better the writer, the less they are interested in fixing the mistakes of other -- unless they've been specifically asked. I think you should stop and think about how you're grouping us before you make assumptions. I made no assumptions. I read all the reviews first. Some of you were polite. Some of you were less than polite. I doubt this young author is able to differentiate at this point. Feb 11th 2009, 1:11pm #248 |
 |
Eleve Osirian And what freedom is there if someone starts telling you how to write? I saw as many complaints of characters being OOC as I saw complaints about grammar and spelling. As I noted in my review, she doesn't have to take any advice given to her, but the least she could do is give a PROPER RESPONSE, not act like a bitch. Regardless of her age, writing abilities, or whatever else you'd like to throw in to that mixture, she did not need to lash out at others like that. Is that what you call maturity and respect? If she can't respect me as another writer, AS A REVIEWER OF HER STORY, then I'm not going to respect her. If she had even half the courage in her own writing abilities as she says she does, she would not have flown off the chart with her ranting and raving. So no, I disagree with you Thranduil, on the basis that this person has their head in the sand. We all get less than flattering reviews, but most of us don't block that person, and continually PM that person about how much they should burn in hell. Feb 11th 2009, 1:20pm #249 |
 |
Aislynn CrowdaughterAs I noted in my review, she doesn't have to take any advice given to her, but the least she could do is give a PROPER RESPONSE, not act like a bitch. Regardless of her age, writing abilities, or whatever else you'd like to throw in to that mixture, she did not need to lash out at others like that. Is that what you call maturity and respect? If she can't respect me as another writer, AS A REVIEWER OF HER STORY, then I'm not going to respect her. If she had even half the courage in her own writing abilities as she says she does, she would not have flown off the chart with her ranting and raving. But at this point, you do not review her as a single writer to a single writer, anymore. To her, it comes over as a lot of negative reviews, done by a group. A group she is bound to see as hostile, at this point. I do welcome concrit, and never deleted a flame to one of my stories, although the ones I have gained so far were anonymous ones I could have gotten rid of. the only "reviews" I ever reported as abuse where obscene spam ones. But still, if I would have a whole group of people starting to pick on my stories, pointing out every possible flaw, and encouraging others to do so, I doubt I would remain very open to critique or looking for mistakes in my story. I would get defensive, too. I think that is true for most of the people here. So - if you were in her situation, how would you react? Welcome the concrit, at this point? Really? Feb 11th 2009, 1:54pm . Edited Feb 11th 2009, 1:56pm #250 |
|