I figured since I've well surpassed the 1000 story mark on my favorites list, and have been on the site for over a decade, I could make a list of the all-time best stories I've had the pleasure of reading on this site. As you can see it's by literary genre, not fandom. Read what you will. Updated as I go through my list, with priority on completed stories.

Best Action-adventure

Best Drama

Best Horror

Best Humor:
"The Great Landscaping Crisis" by MogtheGnome

Best Mystery

Best Romance

Best Short