I HATE YOU I WAS EXPECTING HUMOR AND NOW I’M FULL ON SOBBING AND HEARTBROKEN TT TT

Crying

Heartbreaking... I Love It.

Thank you for sharing this story with us. It was very well-written with superb character work!

Honestly this fic has been one of the best OC fics I've ever read in my life. It's funny, angsty and the romance is superb
Thanks for sharing your fic with us

I love this so much but

(SPOILER kind of)

THE ENDING MADE ME CRY it was so amazing but I WISH THEY HAD MORE TIME! And the bad timing part yet again I HATE YOU FOR MAKING ME FEEL THIS WAY in the way that all amazing authors must be hated ofc

Geez, talk about “right person, wrong time.” I binge read this in a weekend and now my heart is aching and I’m crying, this was such a funny and beautiful story. I loved Effie’s character development, her friendship with Marlene, her relationship with the Black brothers, everything. Also, as sad as it is to say, I am glad you went with this ending. As tragic as it is, it felt right.

Wonderful story - well done!

Wow. A truly amazing story. The ending broke my heart, but it also fits perfectly with canon and the First Wizarding War. Absolutely loved your fic. Thank you so much for writing it!:).

Didn't need my heart anyway

This was an absolutely amazing story! I loved the characters, their development, their relationships, the romance, everything! It was just so well done! And I loved that Effie didn't end up with either of the Black brothers at the end of chapter 49. It felt like a very mature decision because she still wasn't done with her character growth. The epilogue was heartbreaking but I agree that it was the right segue into cannon. I'll definitely be checking out other stories by you! Great job again :)

Tbh your decision to kill off Effie doesn't really affect me, I think her death is a suitable choice (even though not my favorite) so I can respect it. But having Sirius & Effie get together after not doing so in ch 49 did kill my mood because honestly what's the point? Effie deciding not to be in a relationship had a point, her death even has a point, but giving Sirius hope and then ... taking it away in the most cruelist of ways? Maybe it's just because I love Sirius and I'm protective. It'd be one thing for Effie, a friend and his could've been something more, to die - another for Effie, his girlfriend and would've been something more to die. I'm just gonna erase the epiloque from my memory because it SHOULD'VE ended at ch 49; Sirius and Effie's end should have been ch 49.

This is such an awesome story. I have been binge reading it for several days and I cannot believe how you ended it. I think you did the right thing but it was still very sad. I think my favorite part was seeing Effie Picture in the last 10 chapters. Mature. You are an absolutely awesome writer.

This story was absolutely wonderful and Effie's ending was painstakingly appropriate due to the war and upcoming events. I binged read this and I was not disappointed it was beautiful writing!

I don't know, I think I'd take that offer for my shrine.

-Here lies Regulus Black on fleek eyebrow dust.-

Although I wish there was happy ending, it seems better this way to be honest. Brilliant writing, by the way, pretty smooth integration with the canon and great character developments.