No kidding, I'm reading this for the freaking 3rd or 4th time, I've lost count

This story just blew my mind, again. I loved every single detail, especially the Hiccstrid in it. All the feels I got is melting my heart! Hiccup is just perfect in the story, and the way he loves Stoick and Astrid has killed me:)
I really admire how you described all the details in this story, they make this world so real.

I forgot how sad this chapter is! The letter and Stoick's pain is just heart-wrenching. Out of all the Hiccup leaves Berk AUs, I love this the most. All of Hiccup's reasonings and Stoick and Astrid's thought process are so natural and perfect.

This is the third time I'm rereading this story, and it somehow still captures my whole attention as if I was reading it for the first time. This is just so well-written:)

QUE ALGUIEN ME TRAIGA UN OSCAR PARA DÁRSELO A LA DAMA!
Lo juro, nunca vi tanta dedicación en una historia como esta, o sea, investigaste la cultura vikinga para darle mas vida al fanfic, lo juro, me hiciste querer investigar la historia vikinga por esta historia, y eso que soy mas aficionada a la griega, muchas gracias por esto, eres alguien muy inteligente.
AY! No hay palabras que puedan especificar mi estado en este momento!
Sinceramente, te admiro.

..why- why would you be *looking* at Hiccup's crotch in the previews?! WHAT IN HEL!? XD

I said it before in the last chapter and i am gonna say it again!

This story is amazing! and I don't have the words to say how good this is nor do I think there is a word to describe this!
I love to read and I read very fast but I love that this book was good enough that I physically had to force myself to switch the tap so I didn't finish the book in the first day (I ended up successfully pacing myself for 3 days) :)

-Jdog4161

Okay WOW! just WOW!
I loved this fanfic and honestly I think you are the best writer I've come across (including myself), no offense to everyone else. I will definitely read the sequel!

Thanks for a great time of reading this book.
-Jdog4161

I just noticed (on re-reading this story for perhaps the third time- it's really very good) that Stoick not only has no idea that Cattongue IS Hiccup, he doesn't even know that half the reason Astrid is "friendly" towards this stranger is that he "knows" Hiccup (and is implied to be on good terms with him). As far as Stoick is concerned, there is no connection whatsoever between the two young men.

Thank you for the story. It is well written and well thought (and it's honestly hard to find a good HTTYD story). I particularly like the idea of Hiccup running away and people actually knowing he ran away and not assuming he was killed by a nightfury as it is often done.
I wish Stoick would have come to appreciate Cattongue more before discovering he was Hiccup, though.
It would have been fun if, in Epilogue 2, Hiccup called Woodnut by her name and Ruffnut found out Fishlegs had actually name her ;)

the irony of gobber being jealous of himself is not lost on me. i reckon you had a swell time leaving people unknowingly referring to themselves when talking about cattongue-hiccup. not blaming you though, im having an equally amazing time reading it too.

you detest love triangles, which, fair enough, but what about love triads where theyre all hopelessly pining for each other? person a likes both b and c, b likes a and c, and c likes a and b? Would love to see your opinion on the matter. like it? hate it? never thought about it?

I listened to Hans Zimmer 's Stay when Stoick was missing Hiccup. It added a whole new meaning to the sentences, if you care to know.

Why. Is it always a necessity? Hiccup becoming a cripple, that is. What, do you think people missing limbs go 'Oh, if the circumstances that led to my losing my leg were different, I totally would want to lose it again!'
Like, shit, 5 years of experience and a bloody army to call upon, and still, you make him lose his leg? Cause it's *canon*! Cause it's cool to have a main character crippled, cause some loss is meant to happen, cause that way you can have handicapped people empathetic with him! Because if circumstances are different, the one thing that shouldn't change is him being crippled! Fucking hell, what a unique reasoning.

i cried for stoick. the scenes were so emotional. only a few other stories have left me such a mess. excuse my writing but i am truthfully tring to wipe the tears i shed durin the big guy's flash backs. i love this story