Reviews for James Potter and Snape Fistfight in Heaven
Truth chapter 1 . 1/13
Thank you for this. Snape was the worst character in the whole book and deserved every ounce of misery he got. James was a arrogant kid but did the one thing Snape refused to do, grow up.
ALlie chapter 1 . 12/18/2019
Sev! No ! Sev he has to suffer in both part of his life now... Now he has to be alone forever something he never wanted.
gginsc chapter 1 . 10/16/2019
I still think Lily was a lousy friend!
Uu chapter 1 . 10/11/2019
Wow! Lily didn't even thank him for saving her son. For all I know Snape could have left England and left the wizarding world to go to hell.
Myhione Granger chapter 1 . 8/3/2019
fudgefight chapter 1 . 7/8/2019
Dahajo chapter 1 . 6/30/2019
This is the truth about Snape. The Marauders were not nice but they grew up and were able to become someone that people would say "those were good men". Snape joined a group of wizard Nazis and only did Dumbledore's bidding after the prophecy. How many did he torture how many did he kill before the object of his obsession was marked by the prophecy? He was no Hero nor a good person he was simply an Ass.
stuovam chapter 1 . 5/28/2019
Your work is the most disgusting. All your heroes must burn in hell. Even if their death did not fix it. You ignore all the claims of JK Rowling. And even the recognition of Harry Potter. He named his son after Snape. The only green-eyed son.
The fact that the Potters were good is no evidence. These were good words from interested people. And nothing else. You say James grew up, but he is a hypocrite deceiving Lily. Behind her, he continued to offend Snape. He did not attack Snape one on one. Napadinia was only four on one and this proves that James is a coward! He is cruel, he cursed the boy that he walked around like a watermelon for several days. He is a traitor, accusing Remus of a spy without evidence. He is an arrogant upstart, who refused to make the guardian of Dumboldor's secret. He's a fool, he thinks he is getting smarter than Tom. Choosing Peter - he killed his family. He was a traitor to his family when he left them alone, making forays. And if Damboldor didn't take the invisible cloak? And Tom would come and kill Lily and Harry, would James be a hero then? If you want to understand, is it good? Compare Harry and James. Harry's hair stood on end from his father. If Rowling considered James an angel, she would not have carved his insignificance before Harry.
Remus is a coward in life. He would be an outcast like Snape. If he began to contradict the marauders. He left Tonks pregnant. I respect that he poked Harry to respect the sacrifice of his parents.
Sirius is no different from his family. Just bullying calls a joke. He sees only James in Harry. He hated Snape from the first year, just because Snape got into a Slytherir. And this delusions of grandeur destroyed him. He didn't even grow up after prison.
Lily is an arrogant, a licentious girl. Pay attention to the words of Rowling. Lily loved Snape as a friend and would marry Snape if not for Snape’s dark magic. Her behavior near the lake is disgusting and humiliating. He should not smile and flirt when her friend is choking and needs help. I don't want a friend like her to anyone. It's terrible when your best friend doesn't care about your humiliation. She demanded that he not be able to communicate with the slizarents. But she herself did not stop communicating with the marauders. She did not forgive the best friend who made a mistake because of humiliation. But she herself became a part of this humiliation. And she easily managed to forgive James's bullying of her own best friend. What is the difference between bullying Slizarins and bullying marauders? Do they hurt and humiliate others in the same way? Does color magic solve this issue? This is not a joke, when pain and humiliation is inflicted - it is intentional sadism! Only in the seventh year Lily gives James a chance, then when the threat grows over her and you need to find your place in the sun. I am sure that the death of parents gave impetus for a quick wedding. Most likely the same, lack of, in the midst of wars, wanting to link life with muggle-born. Petunia was clearly not waiting for Lily. Like a complete lack of money after school. She would not have been with James if it were not for the war and a place in a magical society.
About Snape. As Rowling says he is gray. He is not perfect, he is mistaken. I am 100% sure that no one would like to be in his place. To be forever hungry, beaten by a beggar, and because of this be humiliated. He does not choose family and childhood. A child runs to Hogwarts wanting salvation from family hell. But from one hell falls into another. It is not his fault that he is morally broken, got into slizarin like his mother. The teachers and the director should give care and help to such a child. As a result, he became an even greater outcast, driven into an animal in a cage, where there is no help and salvation. Where four people under the mantle of the invisible and the card track down and humiliate causing pain. No one appreciates his talent. And when classmates notice this skill, he is glad to admit. It is difficult to resist the received even a drop of preznaniya after so many years. What a pain to see as your only friend, beloved girl, smile at your enemy when he dishonors you intentionally. At the same time she is the headman. She betrayed, but he asks for forgiveness. Having lost her, he drowned in dark magic. He has nothing to lose. Broken people are influenced and fall into sects or informal movements. Especially when society pushes in this direction. All this despair, craves recognition, security.
Snape in general was not obliged to worry about the life of the Potters. How was Lily talking about the way? But valuable his life, he asks two great magicians for help. He is trying to save a woman who denied him and went to the enemy. Since he is a potter nobody. You have no right to condemn him in choosing whom to save is his life. He was not obliged to put a cross on himself and live only for the sake of Harry and "good." Lily is not worth this sacrifice !
You are right. Snape should not have apprehended for Harry’s impudence. The marauders joked at Snape. I think that the ratio of four marauders and one adult Snape is equivalent. If the marauders' jokes are good, then Snape had to joke on Harry. How did Harry's father joke on Snape? James then approved.
wow chapter 1 . 2/6/2019
This is really mediocre.
Pinkypie chapter 1 . 11/13/2018
Aarushi chapter 1 . 1/15/2018
I enjoyed it.
Jilycrazyfangirl chapter 1 . 9/24/2017
Loved it from the bottom of my heart it all turned out like I wanted it to, thank you so much for writing this
Love Emily
joenaruhina57 chapter 1 . 6/12/2017
What a wonderful oneshot. I love every single thing about this story. Thank you...
Guest chapter 1 . 5/19/2017
Good...l must say
voice of the riders chapter 1 . 12/18/2016
I like this description of Snape, and believe that it is accurate.
37 | Page 1 .. Last Next »