Reviews for Hail Odysseus |
---|
Guest chapter 17 . 1/7/2021 Love it! Finally I've read a more violent HPFF and in this case you did it pretty good with the use of weapons. The storytelling was also good, the buildup with H/G was really fantastic too read. Very good ending! Thanks for the fic |
DaSalvatore chapter 17 . 1/4/2021 I'll be honest, this only got a favourite from me because of the Hogwarts and Gellert scenes. Because I have no Earthly clue what you was attempting with Amelia Bones, but it almost spoiled the entire thing for me. Let me be clear, it's NOT that she's not the loyal Hufflepuff of fandom. It's that she's a cartoon villain dressed up to be something else. She's put across as being a black and white thinking Auror who doens't like political games, deals, or the breaking of the law. So what is it she does? - Uses her Niece as an attack dog in Hogwarts against Harry and then blames Harry when it comes back on them. - Tries to force Harry into a Vow that would essentially make him a weapon of the Ministry. - Makes a legal deal with Ginny only to completely break that deal once she gets her guilty plea. - Fully admits, is okay with, and sees nothing wrong with one of her Aurors raping a prisoner just because said prisoner is getting Kissed after. All to keep her Auror happy. This is the stuff an Evil!Dumbledore or Fudge/Umbridge are prone to doing. These are actions by a woman who cares more about her own particular views on the world being kept real than actually doing something against the darkness. These aren't the actions of a black/white mentality cop. Which is fine if not for the fact that's how she kept being forced against. |
Just William chapter 10 . 1/1/2021 Another typo/error "I wanted fire to reign down" should be "I wanted fire to rain down". |
Just William chapter 4 . 12/31/2020 It's not "provide alibies" it's "provide alibis". Just saying. . . . . . |
Guest chapter 17 . 12/2/2020 Thanks! Really fun. |
karmacatchesuptou chapter 17 . 11/30/2020 Damm. I think only posted 2 reviews in my entire life, but this was bloody brilliant! I simply had to congratulate you. Amazing. I love your stories because they are sooo believable. I was imagining a final battle and wondering about the rewards. The ending just makes sense to me and I loved it for it. I know it won't please everyone, but mate, you've made me very happy. Believable, well writen stories are so hard to find, and just so precious. Thank you. God bless. |
FFFudgeUp chapter 17 . 11/11/2020 Great story. I love a confident Harry story. He was dark grey but still loveable and sweet. Thanks for sharing. |
Wondering chapter 17 . 11/5/2020 You seem to be inclined to write stories about a thankless community or at least thankless leaders. Not that this lacks examples in the real world, but just because these exist, I can't help wondering why you (I admit, skilfully) execute such dystopic plots. Surely the world needs a few ideas how to do better, too? |
thatgurl.ashm chapter 17 . 11/6/2020 This was a really great story, but what happened after this? Was Voldemort ever killed, or what? I mean, you can't just leave this here, you have to tell what happened. Otherwise, it was the best dark Harry fanfic I have ever read. |
Kit Willow chapter 17 . 11/1/2020 Great book, keep up the good work |
joycezhanng chapter 11 . 10/31/2020 "abbott is thick as two short planks. I foresee a rewarding career for her as a barmaid, or something." LMFAOOOOO GINNY'S RIGHT. YOU REALLY HAVE NO SHAME WITH BASHING THESE CHARACTERS I'M ABSOLUTELY LIVING FOR IT. |
joycezhanng chapter 7 . 10/31/2020 oh holy shit no I LIKED TRACY. WHAT THE FUCK. UAGHWUGHWKEJGWEHGWEHG |
Anne Bond chapter 16 . 10/29/2020 I figure you have to know... I have read a lot of fics here, and this is the first time I've ever found a malicious (?) or harmful Amelia Bones. Every other time, she was a rigidly good person, practically saintly .. So ya. Thanks for the fic. Cheers! |
Bostonette chapter 2 . 10/11/2020 Fucking garbage already. One chapter in and it's another disappointing story and character list. Glad these authors don't get published, already have enough shit to read in real life. |
Guest chapter 1 . 9/15/2020 Ts |