|Reviews for Sam's Departure|
| Ellyrianna chapter 1 . 1/23/2003
Oh, dear me...how do I review this? I swear I cried. Swear it, and I don't do that often. That was so great...must go read more of your work. And I thought 'You Are My Tomorrow' was good...
| Celeblas chapter 1 . 12/28/2002
OMG! This is such a beautiful poem! it really shows the bond between Frodo and Sam. Wonderful writing.
| Mainecoon of Eriador chapter 1 . 12/28/2002
this is lovely! I am amazed. You did this better than i ever could have. I am very jealous...lol...but in a good way. I am very pleased...
Oh my god that was so sad (bawls into her pillow)
That is one of the most beautiful yet sad lotr poems that i heard, i dont normally cry, but when i read this one i felt the tears in my eyes. I hope to read more of your work. You are very talented.
Wow. That was so beautiful! I mean, REALLY beautiful! After I read it I had to stop and just breathe for a minute because it touched me so deeply. I cried. I AM crying still! That is so sad and so sweet and so BEAUTIFUL! You are extremely talented. I'm going to add you to my favorite authors list.
You know, that was sad, but in a way it also wasn't. I mean, it *was*-but there was hope as well. They're still together. Always.
*wipes away a tear* As usual, beautiful. Wow. I'm glad I have all day to read these. :)
awww... that's sad.
Wicko (Lazy to login)
I think I DID write a logged-in review ah well...I'll say it again, this ROCKS!
The entire poem is beautiful and sad, but also kind of peaceful.
ahh, that is so sad!
I add you into favourite author thingy now!
Wow *sobs* That was amazing. You are very talented, my god I wish I could write like that. You captured so many emotions so well, bravo! :)
*bawls* that's so beautiful! *sobs* wow...i don't think i've ever cried this much from a poem before...it's so fitting, though. i think that's exactly how they both would want it...if frodo had to die so soon and all...or not soon...or whichever...*dives for tissue box again*
*sniff* That was absolutely amazing. Great job.
OMG! I have never cried when I've read poetry before, but this, this made me cry. It's so beautiful! You do have a true talent for writing. OK, OK, I gotta stop crying (lol). That last little bit was like my breaking point. OMG! I gotta read something happy and funny. I know! I'll go read that list of "How to tell if you're obsessed with Frodo/Elijah Wood"! That'll make me laugh... 8)
Oh my gosh! *wipes away tears* Wow... That was really great! I had to read it over; it was even better than I expected when I clicked on it..._
The friendship Frodo and Sam shared was so pure and beautiful. Very well done!
*bursts into tears* AWWW~ crying...so cute, and sad and and and...I don't know. Good job. *goes off to bawl in her corner some more*
Ocarina Rune Scholar
*sniff* Very moving. Naturally, my anticlimatical *sniff* went and made me laugh... Awesome job. -ORS
Miyako Inoue, Queen of Cheese
AAAAAAAAH! YOU MADE ME CRY! This is so sweet! The more of your poetry I read, the more I realize, you have a gift. A true gift. *sigh* I'm gonna go read something comical... I need to stop crying... *stumbles off, running into a wall* I meant to do that...
that was such a good poem...i'm not really into poetry but that was magnificent
*wipes away a tear* Oh, that was lovely!
Oh...Oh, Oh wow..
You don't know how emotionally deep that was..Wow..~stomach goes all funny~ That was just..I've never read ANYTHING like that before...I can't even begin to..just...WOW.
The Wandering Blue Andalite
NOOOOOO! *Reviwer brust into tears* What do you mean Frodo dies? I'm only half way through 'The Fellowship of The Ring' Does he die in one of the other books? *Reviewer crys loudyly* BUT he was my favorite! That was SUCH a sad poem! SO sad,but yet SO beautifully written.
GREY Havens. Spell it right.
Awwwwww! That was sad! ;_;
But u do know that u don't die in Valinor, don't u? So Frodo couldn't have died.
Very good poetry. One thing though, Frodo doesn't die. He went to Valinor to be healed, not to die! But I do like the poetry.
cold-fire zorra ()
I'm crying...that was so sad.
Beautiful and sad. But I thought Frodo wouldn't die; once he reached the Blessed Realm he would become immortal, and so would Sam and Bilbo. Hopeful thinking I guess.
That was sad, depressing as you say. It was good, and the rhymes and all. ) (And I'm too lazy to log in)
Ok, my eyes are literally tearing up right now, so I'm going to go off somewhere now...
Oh, that is SO sad! It makes me want to cry. But truly, it is a beautiful poem. Many thanks for it.
This story is great! I've probably read it at least five times, but it's still so sad! Then again, I'm a sap when it comes to sad Frodo/Sam stories _ Anyway, keep up the good work!
Christina Miller ()
Hmph. Depressing, yes, but other than that quite good.
Meaghan Hare ()
Hey, it's me again. That was beautiful! You know something is really good when it brings tears to your eyes! I see you have a soft spot for Sam, me too, he was always my favorite character! As I poet myself, I would think it means a lot to you to tell you that you have wonderful skills! Keep writing I love it!
ooo I really liked this one! you are very talanted please write more!
Wow...that was even better than the other one! You have a real talent for writing poetry~keep it up!
Someone else should review this!
Ooh, very good! It's very well written. Too few people seem to read poetry these days, although I don't consider myself a poet. (Even though I've submitted two poems)