Reviews for To Be Forever Faithful
Happyhobbitlife chapter 1 . 1/5
I cannot work out how to respond in this app but I think you for your reply and your dedication to this story! Kudos!
Happyhobbitlife chapter 2 . 1/4
I'm enjoying your writing style and description of how the wardens live, but struggling to accept the idea of Belegwen having lived for several millenia! It might just be me but i feel like a few thousand years would be much more realistic
wynnathewarrior chapter 60 . 6/13/2023
I have never read a more detailed and well-written fan fiction with an OC!
This is incredible, the writing style, the characters, even the non-canon events...WOW! This will not be long away from my Favorites page!
ZapperTrapper44 chapter 60 . 5/25/2023
This was such a great fic that I was sorry to see it end. Extremely well done especially because of the amount of effort and time you have given of yourself for this project. It will definitely go into my reread list. Thanks so much for sharing your story
Brittabritt chapter 1 . 1/5/2023
I really enjoyed this story, and that epilogue was epic! Thank you for writing this story
Ten Duel Commandments chapter 1 . 4/8/2021
I go back to re-read this occasionally, especially the ending since I don't read too many reunification-after-sailing endings. I love the story so much. :)
guest chapter 60 . 3/21/2021
Your story was wonderful! I like the way you wrote Haldir and your OC Belegwen was a nice character; strong, independent but also with her own hidden insecurities and wounds of the past. Their relationship was fascinating to read as it changed with time and with the revelation of Haldir's secret. Of course I am very happy you didn't let him die at Helm's Deep. Rumil was my favorite character, from the supportive ones and Orophin's role was touching. All the others, either cannon or OCs that surrounded the couple, contributed to the plot perfectly. The epilogue with the reunion of all the families and everyone's 'happily ever after' was awesome!
claretta chapter 60 . 1/2/2021
Oh my gosh. I haven't read a fanfic in years and picked this one up on a whim- oh my gosh. It's all I can say. I adored every minute of this and have read non-stop since I found it. You spun a beautiful tale, I loved the characters and the intricate storyline and how well it was all woven and tied together. And that ending! My heart is full. I am happy. Thank you for this amazing piece.
Arwan chapter 60 . 12/31/2020
Thank you so much Ma'am for finishing this story! Really loved it..can't believe this story was first published when I was an year old. When I first read it in 2016 I was hooked and I really wanted for this story to have an ending. Fast forward to December 2020 it is done! Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Wishing you a happy 2021 and stay safe
Addy White chapter 60 . 12/31/2020
I'm so sad that it's finally the end!
What a beautiful ending, it was the beginning of a new life. I don't know what to say. Orophin accepting and realising that he is loved, brought me nearly to tears. He also found love! (oh well, nearly there.)
Belegenna sounds like a sweet elfling, and Halendil will most likely be a protective older brother.
I'm glad to see the end of Belegwen's tale, to see how much she has changed.
Thank you for this beautiful epilogue. :)
mystarlight chapter 60 . 12/30/2020
I am mesmerized by your amazing story! Thank you so much for sharing. It was wonderful to read about this brilliant world you created. I am looking forward to hearing more about the Middle Earth. Where is the group you wrote about available? Happy New Year to you! May all your dreams come true!
Scylla's revenge chapter 1 . 12/30/2020
Wow a twenty year effort! That's really impressive and I'm looking forward to how this unfolds!
mystarlight chapter 59 . 12/15/2020
It is so sad to hear that it is the final chapter of such an amazing story. Looking forward to epilogue.
PrettyRecklessLaura chapter 59 . 12/14/2020
Can't wait for the epilogue!
Addy White chapter 59 . 12/13/2020
Awww.
All words have left me, but here I am, in my bed, at nighttime, with a huge grin on my face.
Thank you!
I am awaiting the epilogue eagerly!
696 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »