Reviews for An Eye For An Eye
Earthdragon chapter 22 . 4/9/2023
Small correction to the beginning of this chapter. Mirkwood's former name was actually Eryn Galen (or The Green Wood), before it was poisoned by Sauron's darkness. After the Ring was destroyed, and the elves were able to cleanse their home of orcs and spiders, it was renamed Eryn Lasgalen (Wood of Green Leaves).
Dasgun chapter 1 . 11/23/2022
..-.
aredhel-of-goldolin chapter 22 . 9/11/2020
I just finished this, and let me tell you that I am absolutely floored by the amazingness of this story. Literally everything was perfect, and it was an extremely enjoyable read!
Wolf'sVine chapter 22 . 7/18/2019
Whoa, this has been an adventure, a harrowing one. But it was inspirational too! I loved how it all started with Aragorn playing a prank on his brother and how Legolas instincts were whispering of storm-clouds. and I loved the deep love and respect that Estel and Elrohir and Elladan have for Lord Elrond. And how much they kinda don't wanna get him pissed at them! Legolas shares that as well! And I adore the deep and abiding friendship between the four, especially Legolas and Strider. And I wouldn't have minded reading more about Thranduil! And... honestly, I could go on, but I'm sleepy, so I'm just gonna say that this fic was so good I ended up reading all night and it was a true delight to read it, even as super tired as I am!
MistressOfImladris chapter 1 . 1/4/2019
I've been trying to find this story for so long! I read it ages ago, but couldn't remember the title or author for the life of me - I finally found it!
I'm thinking of chapter 14 . 9/18/2018
Quitting. You over complicating the story too much.
Also underestimating the damn elves. They're over 2000 years old, Legolas knows the terrain the must been aware of possible traps and four man, that you have before described as loud, just get the drop on them? Wtf?
At least Aragorn had the privilege of being set upon by 17 individuals.
Also, Elrond is Old and experienced and he couldn't come up with a better plan than just do exactly as the enemies says at every turn? Really?
late guest chapter 12 . 9/17/2018
It's official - Nolad is the most disgusting of the bunch. Don't get me wrong the others are far more hateful, but nolad takes the hat on the disgusting front... Because he is SO much BETTER than everyone around him, the guy is a prejudiced coward and an horrible friend that just stands back making excuses for others behaviors and his own inaction and thinking himself so superior. Poor poor Nolad - what is an upstanding elf to do in a situation like this except simply accept the utter deterioration/degradation of a friend without truly trying to stop and in fact only supporting it?
On another tangent can one actually do what you described with an arrow the way you described it?
Axa chapter 22 . 1/8/2018
It feels so odd to review on a story that was written when I was 3, but here we are. This story was amazing and super well written. Even though you may look back and cringe at what your younger self felt was good writing, know that it really is great writing and continues to reach audiences in 2018.
AndurilofTolkien chapter 22 . 2/21/2017
aw great job
MerenaRose chapter 19 . 1/27/2017
Oh boy!
MerenaRose chapter 12 . 1/27/2017
Someone save ESTEL! Gah! I'm dying from the suspense!
MerenaRose chapter 9 . 1/27/2017
This is crazy intense!
MerenaRose chapter 8 . 1/27/2017
Eessh protective Elrond is slightly scary.
MerenaRose chapter 2 . 1/27/2017
This is great! Can't wait to read more.
TimeturnerJay chapter 22 . 7/24/2016
This story was wonderful. It stayed true to Tolkien's world and the characters, and even the funny passages felt natural and always brought a smile to my face. The only thing I regret is the fate of the poor bow. Stay strong, Legolas, you will receive a much better one when you venture to Lorien a few decades from now.I know that this story is quite old already, and I don't know if you still read the reviews, but in case you do, I wanted to let you know that I thoroughly enjoyed it and that I look forward to its many sequels.
821 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »