|Reviews for I Know Not, and I Cannot Know--Yet I Live and I Love|
| Indigo2004 chapter 1 . 5/29
Highkey made me cry. The most beautiful fic I’ve read recently. I would really like to see more with Severus having another shot at life. Thank you so much for this touching piece of writing OP.
it truly was an incredible journey
| SaffronFlowers chapter 1 . 5/26
This had me crying and crying. Wow. A ff has never made me feel this way. Thank you for writing this.
| Forsoothandconquest chapter 1 . 5/14
This feels like a perfect representation of Snape
| backpackback chapter 1 . 4/6
What a masterpiece. I cried from laughing, then really cried. Perfectly done.
| Guest chapter 1 . 2/27
I ugly cried at the end. You’ve characterized Severus Snape perfectly. This was beautifully written.
| Sakut Uastk chapter 1 . 2/28
Goodness, this almost had me crying in class! The characterization of everyone, and Snape's and Luna's cautious friendship was wonderfully written. Such a lovely story, even if I had to put my phone down a couple times to halt the oncoming tears.
| Occhi-Blu chapter 1 . 2/15
Here I’m crying my eyes out. That one was beautiful! Thank you for sharing it
| Luin-fanel chapter 1 . 2/5
I'm NOT crying... Is just sweat in my eyes for read nonstop this marvellous fanfic.
Thanks a lot for writing it. I didn't know I need it until today.
| Hectorsmom chapter 1 . 1/11
This was beautiful. I hope it happened and that the books were to busy to share.
| Mike699 chapter 1 . 12/18/2022
This was very nice. I'm a pretty "tough guy" but I still got a little teary at the end there.
| Guest chapter 1 . 12/6/2022
Ohhhhhhh this made me have so many feelings. Awesome fic thank you!
| Quinn chapter 1 . 11/4/2022
I've always searched for proper words to defend Professor Snape whenever I am asked why I like him, and you, author-chan, have provided me with the exact reasons and words. Thank you! Also, I am deeply in love with your writing style! It's very elegant!
| Guest chapter 1 . 11/3/2022
This is such a great story that fits the characters so well. I want to think this was canon. I can see Luna really being able to get through to some of these characters like only she can. I read another story where Luna ends up with toms journal and a similar journey happens where she helps him see there is more to life than hate and pain and bitterness. Thank you for sharing!
| Milijolumu chapter 1 . 11/4/2022
Thank you for this wonderful and beautiful story!
I had never expected needing a story about friendship between Luna and Snape - but here I am and I'm glad that I have found it.
I like how you wrote this story in little flashes of different scenes throughout the years, describing little bits and pieces that in the bigger picture showed the slow change that they brought. And that you kept both of them true to their character while explaining what was going on behind Snapes facade.
I was filled with dread, though, noticing how you stayed true to the books and knowing what was to come. And I cried ugly in the end. Snape had only just begun to see a slim shimmer of hope and it still was not enough to change the outcome. I was really hoping that their friendship would change the outcome of the books (I just hate the canon ending in general), but after reading through it all, I'm glad that it didn't. This story about loss and love and hope wouldn't feel as impactful as it does if it had a cliché "happy ending" - in a more subtle way it still does. A very emotional and in the end peaceful happy ending and I think that's what makes this story all the more special. It gives a deeper meaning to it and makes you pause and think.
I hope that all of us can one day leave this world with both love and hope in our hearts.
| OneTiredPunkin chapter 1 . 10/27/2022
I can't recall if I've commented on this before but even if I have you deserve another. This is amazing. From beginning to end I was hooked. I bawled at the end even though I KNEW what to expect. This is by far one of my absolute favorite fics and I've recommended it to so many people. Thank you for sharing your story. It makes my heart so happy.