|Reviews for Trumpet of the Swan|
| Ameerah al-Azim chapter 4 . 1/5/2013
| chye pamilton chapter 2 . 12/11/2012
Who ever wrote this story this is a lot of reading to do. thank you
| Equilly chapter 5 . 7/30/2011
I'm sad this is on hiatus! You have a beautiful writing style, and you've developed your characters so well.
| Equilly chapter 1 . 7/30/2011
Haha, I will give you a real review, but honestly- who DOESN'T hate the name Teleporno? I just about died the first time I saw it :)
| Saffron Blade chapter 5 . 3/27/2011
I've actually never read a Silmarillion story before, but I like the idea that Celeborn and Galadriel meet when they are younger and before the kin-slaying.
I definitely agree that Celeborn sounds better than Teleporno.
I was really surprised by the closeness of relationships that you created between Galadriel and Maglor, and the other cousins as well. It's a very refreshing aspect, as many authors tend to ignore that they are family and that Pr. Tolkien definitely wrote that elves loved and supported all of their family, no matter how distant of relations they were. So I'm really glad to see that.
I really like how this has turned out so far and I hope that you one day do finish this.
| Riddle7777 chapter 5 . 2/1/2010
Oh i just loove your story! I was not such a lotr fan before i read your fic and i thank you for resoring my faith!
| LucastaPastaTheShamanRamen chapter 5 . 10/11/2009
It's a true shame that this tale was never finished ;_; Its beauty outshone even the Silmarils!
| SoConfusified chapter 5 . 3/7/2008
I still find it the fact that 75% of the bloodshed (and various other not-so-nice things) in the First Age is somehow related to the Silmarils hard to wrap my head around. Oh yes, and how can we forget the oaths of his sons as he died. Thanks for that Feanor.
Okay, I suppose I should actually review your story now.
Well written! I'm glad to see someone had the guts to take on this particular story thread (Galadriel is a rather difficult character to write for). I also like the fact that you used as much canon material as possible. (congratulations on getting the geography and timeline correct for the most difficult book ever!) Cannot wait for the update!
*faves & alerts*
| Noriko333 chapter 5 . 7/1/2006
i know that you haven't updated in about - two years! but i really do hope that you would. not to sound rude or anything but there are people who are desperatly waiting for you to update. so i hope that i don't sound rude or anything, but we haven't heard anything of this story for 2 years and yeh.
| Gryphaena chapter 5 . 12/20/2005
Hmm, if I remember what I read in The Unfinished Tales correctly, she leaves Alqualonde with Celeborn. I hope you can update again!
| Silver chapter 5 . 12/27/2004
Oh, wow...This has to be the best Galadriel and Celeborn romance I have come across! It's perfect! Well, minus the fact that you haven't updated in quite some time, but I understand writer's block. Usually these types of stories take place in Doriath, you know, Galadriel is cast into exile with some of her kin, arrives in Doriath and is greeted by Celeborn and King Elu Thingol. It is very refreshing to find another take on my favorite romance!
But of course the real angst is yet to come! We all know what happens in the not so far future, and boy do I want to see what happens then! Ai! Just think of all of the possibilities! Artanis really needs to realize her feelings for Celeborn, although I think your Artanis is very well in character. She wouldnt just rush into the arms of some suitor, even if she was fond of him!
Well, I am babbling now-but I cant seem to help myself! I very much love this story and wait on the edge of my seat for the next very well written chapter! Bravo! Well Done!
| Me who else chapter 5 . 8/26/2004
All I can say is wow! Wow, wow, wow. This is one of the best stories I have ever read, and I mean it. Very weel written , interesting, exciting, and original. I love how you portray both Celeborn and Galadriel, and I agree with you about Celeborn's Quenya name. It just ain't pretty. Haha, keep up the great work, and you better update this soon! Or else I'll send my llama after you! *Cackles*
(Not that I have a llama, but hey, I couldn't think of anything better.) :D
| IloveYourStory chapter 5 . 8/19/2004
Dude, you better not abandon this fic! I am in love with it. Well, not really, but you get the point. But I do love it! I've been wating for a while for you to update it, and now I'm starting to sweat, thinking that maybe you might not finish it. And I think "No..." The "O's" could go on for much longer but I've decided to not take up to much space. But please keep writing! I beg you! Great, wonderful, job.
| Feanin chapter 1 . 8/7/2004
I can't wait to find out what both Celeborn and Artanis are going to do during the Kin-slaying. I love your piece. I myself prefer to think of Celeborn as a Telerin elf. IT seems to add more depth to him.
| lizdarcy2 chapter 5 . 6/20/2004
Hey! I've just read all of your story so far, and I love it! I have always wondered what could have happened if Tolkien had written Celeborn as a Teleri. I hope you update soon!