Reviews for A Gryffindor Tried and True
seekerchick06 chapter 28 . 11/24/2007
Yay! I loved it! New fave!
panther73110 chapter 28 . 9/28/2007
will there be a squel
Summercloud chapter 28 . 9/17/2007
This was REALLY good. What a rush! I knew they'd save Harry, of course, but it was the getting there that was the fun part. And I'm so glad I discovered this after it was done! Thank you for letting me read it!
KilljoyClone chapter 28 . 9/11/2007
aw... a neville triumphs story. it was so beautiful... you did a really good job with this.
YamiFix chapter 28 . 9/6/2007
loved this! the suspense made my heart beat 10miles an hour!

luv ya

FOXANBU
Jimbocous chapter 28 . 7/29/2007
Truly a nice story, and very well-executed from top to bottom. Any chance for a sequel? There's a lot of potential to explore with Malfoy's conversion, not matter how moot DH made it. Hope to see you back writing here, and good luck with your original works as well. Thanks for a fun read.
shogi chapter 28 . 7/24/2007
Amazing! Amazing! Well done! I totally loved it! There was suspense to keep me here and a wonderful plot line to keep me interested! The best combo there is! Excellent work!
Clever Lass chapter 27 . 7/11/2007
Just re-read this story and enjoyed it just as much, if not more, than I did the first time. Thanks again for sharing it... and welcome to my fav's list.
Pat Cross chapter 28 . 7/2/2007
GREAT story! Very well done. It was about time someone put Neville in a brave role, and you did it well.
lilkyonkyon chapter 28 . 6/11/2007
Hah, this story was great! I'm glad to read about Harry Potter not saving the day for once. (Don't get me wrong, Harry is great, but he's really a sponge for glory.) Not only was this story so entertaining, it just seems so true. I could imagine something like this happening, down to the Draco Malfoy change of heart. (I'm waiting for that boy to come around, even if he did help assassinate Dumbledore...)

You did a great job writing this and making it interesting. Thanks for doing it!
lilkyonkyon chapter 13 . 6/11/2007
"Maybe . . . maybe Saint Potter's life outside of Hogwarts isn't as rosy as I thought it to be. And maybe, just maybe, Father's way-Voldemort's way-is wrong."

And what happened then...?

Well...in Hogwarts they say

That Malfoy's small heart

Grew three sizes that day!

(Sorry, it just reminded me of that so much...)
HollyWd chapter 28 . 6/1/2007
I love your writing, and this story. DO you have any plans for a sequel? I would love to read a Neville-centric sequel based on the last scene about curing his parents.
coffee walnut chapter 28 . 5/15/2007
Interesting read... Well rounded and realistic characters! All in all a good read! Good work!
aradonai chapter 28 . 4/15/2007
Brilliant story! I loved that you focused on Neville. And I love Draco's decision. Great job.
Kirinin chapter 28 . 4/15/2007
That was bloody well marvelous, not to mention truly original - the hunting cats, the shifting garden with dangers lurking around every corner, the race against time - wow, the entire story was so filled with tension that I have no clear idea of what the hell time it is... oh, 4:30AM. Damn.

Some real highlights of this story were the way that Draco worked so well with Ron and the way that Snape, Hermione and Neville worked so well together. That latter trio - I kept having to remind myself when you said 'trio' that you were referring to them and not the Gryffindor Trio. And was amazed all over again how you'd thrown these three very different characters together and yet they worked perfectly as a team.

Neville saving the day in general was truly special. He's a great, often underappreciated character, and it was fun to see him shine.

Snape's speech while he awarded points made me grin like a fool and press my fingers to my lips in utter shock. That was so well done!

The harm your three heroes constantly came to was surprising but good. When the pterodactyl-like thing caught Hermione I was beside myself, as when Snape fell, when Hermione caught fire, etc. I was surprised to note that Neville never encountered mortal peril, but I suppose you were making the point that he got the chance to play the hero.

The initial scene where Harry goes from cursing him to fighting to protect him was startling in its suddenness, but Harry all over - as was his first concern on waking, making sure that Draco and Snape were well. Finally, I am really fond of your Draco in general. You built him to be snarky and sometimes annoying but also genuinely good... a challenging sort of character to write. The bit where Draco's world sort of dissolves when he realizes how truly important Harry is to him was wonderful.

Ron being the responsible one and looking after Harry was great - he was okay with changing bandages, holding Harry, whatever was needed. Though... it did seem like you got his dialect a bit off, adding apostrophes to shorten his words when Rowling never has.

The only other bit of CC I have is that it was slightly unrealistic for Harry's illness to be so cut-and-dry in terms of its statute of limitations, so to speak. It seems awfully precise to say that after sunset, Harry can't recover (or was it that they had to start brewing the potion by sunset? Either way...) However, since this is a magical dysfunction and not a typical disease, I guess it *could* have a set time-frame in which it operates; I am willing to suspend disbelief on this point. Just seemed - more contrived than necessary. There was really more than enough tension without a truly specific deadline.

I love this story and am adding it to my C2, Kirinin's Fics of Worth. Thanks for writing, I really enjoyed it! :)

-Kirinin
636 | « Prev Page 1 .. 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 18 .. Last Next »