It's very funny so far, but you might want to check the formatting. When the italics start, they do not stop in this chapter.

This story is amazing, I love all the references everywhere, the characters from the Silmarillion turning up all over the place, the lovely humour and flowing narration. Wonderful, just what I need to lift my spirits :D

Go Luthien! Of course she woudl defeat Mary-Sues just like that! (However, she kind of is one...)

PLEASE CONTINUE! I'm begging you- this is hilarious and fixes all Elrond's broken relationships, and it's a lovely jumble of family, friends, too-intense lovers, everyone who has ever existed, chaos, and hilarity!

So maybe Boromir's brain will absorb the contents of the Noldolantë and he won't want to take the Ring anymore!

Ha! You gotta love this story! Keep going (:

I am almost literally in tears.

God almighty, you know your stuff.

But I'm going to SERIOUSLY need to break out the mental bleach after reading this. *MY MIIINNNNDDDD!*

That was hilarious. My brother has stopped looking at me strangely when i cackle gleefully and instead just are a very good and funny writer and i want you to PLEASE update. PLEASE?

Wow, really funny so far, can't wait to read more!

Oh. My. Goodness. That has to be the most hilarious lotr story i have ever had the fortune to read!

IloveitIloveitIloveitIloveit. .It.

Brillancy! I could hardly breathe sometimes for laughing.

love you~

...and Elrond.

That has got to be the funniest story in the world. The names of the fangirls are what really crack me up. And no, my name is weird but i did not make it up i just translated it and it looks weird in English letters. Anyway, i love it, keep it up.

ooh! ooh! need more! please! i know the thing says it hasnt been updated for ages, but i'm going to ignore what minimal brain power i have and ask for more... so damn good! it makes me want to squee like a fangirl... but instead i fell off my chair from laughing too much. seriously. i'm blaming you for my abused rear end. SO FUNNY! truly brilliant, thats all i can say. thanks for the tremendous laugh!

ps. please please please don't stop this!

pps. i want to hear more about glorfindel and erestor... hehe... surreptitiously groping... hehe...

I recently checked this out to see if it had been updated, and lo and behold, it had...which tells you it had been a while since I last checked! But it was worth the wait. All the "new" stuff (i.e., chapters 17-20) is hilarious! Sam and the horse...Finrod! I love Finrod!...Elrond's kidnapping *cackle*...and aw, I'll miss Denethor...he's not coming back as Denethor the White, is he? But in any case, I do hope you'll find the time to update again soon. The effect of reading four new chapters has been to make me long for more goodness from The Fellowship of Eru-Knows-How-Many!

-Rose