|Reviews for The Gift of Iluvatar|
| shirebound chapter 1 . 3/13/2003
Oh, it's back! Ariel, what a gem, what perfection, what an amazing piece this is. (Would you ever consider a chapter 2? Did Indil watch Frodo and Sam honored by the King?)
I love this story. Love love love it.
| katakanadian chapter 1 . 3/12/2003
Hey Ariel! This is my favourite piece amongst your stories. Since Shirebound recently wrote In the Keeping of the King I think it's great that people are now reminded to read this which provides such a beautiful setup and inspiration for her piece.
| FreaknessForDummies chapter 1 . 3/12/2003
I honestly don't have words to describe that. Must've been the BEST thing I've ever read that even comes close to how Tolkien wrote. Geez, you almost had me in tears! The whole thing was absolutely amazing. Wow. I'm ranting like an idiot. Please believe me when I say that was one of the most moving things I have read in my entire life. Just the descriptiveness and the feeling in it. You wouldn't believe how late it is that I'm writing this (almost 1AM), but I had to finish this in one sitting; it'd be nothing short of a tragedy to stop halfway through. You're an excellent writer, what can I say?