|Reviews for Horry Patter and the Philologer's Stone|
| xihute chapter 31 . 11/5
Such great story. Truly something new and exciting. Magic is amazing, something that breaks reality and reason, yet avoiding falling into dream-like logic. Something that boggles the mind.
I hope the story will continue one day.
| ThreateningMedicine chapter 10 . 8/1
im really really loving this story
its a great big complex puzzle teafhing me about all sorts of crazy ideas, and wow did i not realise how ideas most people would find 'boring' can be applied in such fun and ingenious ways! wowowowow! I have yet to figure out to secret of chapter five even upon multiple rereadings, but that's the curse you author will have when you're smarter than most of the readerbaseyour audience will take forever to figure it out.
| punmaster chapter 22 . 6/11
This deserves more love, AAAH. I keep coming back to this story and wanting more, but its sad that there isn't... pain. It's been five years...
| Guest chapter 31 . 10/26/2022
Maybe continue and end story? Please?
| ThreateningMedicine chapter 2 . 4/19/2022
The cellar creeped open? Are they going somewhere? And wherever they're going to, it is the most precious thing in the universe. Is it the library? Is it the fantasy-world? Maybe, a book was picked on random from the library of knowledge and was made 'flesh'? Maybe, the book that records history and life was corrupted, causing history and the world and fate itself to be rewritten? Horrifying, that. It's impossible to know. Is it a coincidence that the chapter they are 'going into a cellar' is also the chapter that real?albus manages to communicate with horry? Three times? Does that refer to the amount of times they are allowed to meet and speak? 'And this is the first'? Definitely about meeting, right? He wishes it was later, why? Is it because there's something that Horry will do/learn later on that he'll need immediate guidance on? And that prior guidance won't really make sense until what happens, happens? He also talks of terms. Are there rules to this? Was there a REASON this world was made, because that is what the existence of terms implies.
There's so much that could be interpreted in so many different ways. Befriend the librarian? Does that mean that the librarian is in on this? Or is it because she will help achieve the goal of learn as much as possible. real?albus calls horry 'harry', and dismisses the soul stuff as nonsense. I don't, there's so much going on that i can't even think about ALL of it and I love it
| ThreateningMedicine chapter 1 . 4/19/2022
Could this be the "joke" that chapter 3's beginning quote speaks of? The "joke made flesh"? Or maybe not... looking for a story about a man looking for stories? It's unlikely it's a joke - his hands are shaking. He's not in a jovial mood, it seems. Why would someone look for a story about a man looking for stories? Is this a reference to the library that is talked of later that writes of everything that is, was, and will ever be - including people's lives? Is the old man trying to find that? Is he reading his own life book? But it'd be impossible to learn anything that hasn't already occured? What is he possibly trying to do? Trying to find something? Like, for example, a plothole in the story indicating something wrong with reality? Or, perhaps, does he suspect that his mind has been altered, and is tryna dig in deep into the book to tell if his minds been messed with or not? Why?
| ThreateningMedicine chapter 3 . 4/19/2022
"A joke made flesh"?
An interesting way to phrase it. And it seems the "flesh" has been emphasised. The only thing I could possibly think of for this is the verse “Jesus Christ, being the Word made flesh through the divine power of God, is what a real believer should know.”
So, something spiritual and simply imagined becoming real? Words, a joke, a fantasy becoming real somehow? That's horribly creepy. Literally, "word"s becoming flesh (although, i do know that word did not literally mean word in the bible"). Somebody "made" the joke/fantasy real? Who would do that? Why?
It seems there is a tone of regret laid in these... are these flashforwards to when they finally manage to break out? Aw, if only this story was finished! Then we would know the plot twists that lie ahead!
| ThreateningMedicine chapter 31 . 4/17/2022
PLEAAAAAASE continue, this story is FIRE
I swear, it's one of my favourite stories I've ever seen in fanfiction. It's so hooking. I dream of the day you'll write OC fiction, because it sounds just so great!
| Alien52332 chapter 8 . 1/21/2022
"Nah, not too bad. Audience gets a'mediate understandin' of the new rules. Players gotta sort it out right quick, though! More balls, less balls, more players, more goals,no goalies, refs become players, points for blood, sides swap, players become balls—things like that. Usually better te let one poor soul chase the snikt, than 'ave the rules changin' on ye constantly."
This is my favorite paragraph of all time. Can’t stop laughing.
| Alien52332 chapter 8 . 1/21/2022
| HwaseungOz chapter 31 . 1/2/2020
This is very weird and I like it
| anon chapter 31 . 11/21/2019
One of the most original and interesting pieces of fanfiction I've ever read. Love your stuff man. Hope you continue it one of these days.
| Errant chapter 31 . 8/31/2019
This is one of the most interesting and original fics I've read. I very much hope you will continue it
| Guest chapter 10 . 5/29/2019
I'm rereading things with a significantly better understanding of crypto-currency and zero knowledge proofs than my last read through and this is AMAZING.
Do you have any plans to continue the story?
| Guest chapter 31 . 5/28/2018
Keep it up!