Oh my gosh this was freaky good—it explains so much about the Hallows in terrifying detail—this is now canon for me!

What an amazing idea and the execution was perfect! I had goosebumps all over my body!

A very interesting take on the Hallows. I would dearly like to see a follow up of this just to see the fall out.

interesting enough; that said, dumbledore putting on the stone/ring wasn't because of the stone itself. voldemort had laid a compulsion to put the ring on in order to activate the curse he left on it, it was a trap he laid to protect his horcrux, not something inherent in the ring itself. iirc he even says that he put it on due to a compulsion spell on the ring.

Frighteningly plausible! :)

I thought about this idea once but you delivered an excellent story.

holy shit. I've literally never thought of it this way

I’ve never seen this idea in any fic, and I’m having a hard time figuring out why...it’s a pretty damned good theory.

GREAT idea, destroy them all now!

don't ask me if I'm paranoid. ask me if I'm paranoid enough.

But then harry would need to act like a not-retard. This harry might marry hermione. Or at least protect her from marrying the waste of space. ‘Let’s go fetch your folks’ - and turn it into a six month trip to reconnect with them, for example.

Great take.

This is awesome.

Wow... my mind is blown. That is a hugely different take on what I read, but ultimately just as believable, although I would not be lik "Er, nothing much..." I'd be like "Oh My God! We have to kill them NOW!" But then again, I am bit excitable.

Great take on the story!

That raises a valid point

It would have been the only time during Book Seven that Harry showed any sense.

Wish I had a basilisk fang to stab that wretched book, instead of just reselling it to the used book store.