Reviews for A Fish Out of Water (ASOIAF SI)
litwater44 chapter 25 . 11/15
Awsome story
nienerz chapter 25 . 10/20
*Drunk bridesmaid voice* "YOU'RE GETTING MARRIED!"
nienerz chapter 24 . 10/20
A sister makes her brother promise to protect her child .. promise me

I hope Sansa doesn't get burned to death
nienerz chapter 8 . 10/20
DEAD! oh fuck
amk41196 chapter 25 . 8/30
Sad there's no more updates...
Guest chapter 25 . 8/20
I read your reddit comment and you said you'd update this story one day so i was hoping you'd do it soon?
Ahtu chapter 24 . 6/6
Typical Cat... Fuck everything up for everyone, then demanded promises for them to fix the mess he's made... As if she didn't make any of those messes in the first place.

He should not have promised that... Don't make promises you can't make good on.
Ahtu chapter 20 . 6/6
Their arguments make little sense... They're exhausted sure. But so are Stannis's men, they've been fighting for even longer than they have...
Ahtu chapter 7 . 6/5
They were a silver bullet, until you mucked it all up with indecisive and vague orders...

What he needed to do, is get the right ppl into the right positions, to all strike at the same time. To avoid butterfly effects mucking up his plans. He could have set the board for himself in a very effective manner.

Personally I'd have focused more on Daenerys, she's the faction he really needs on his side in the long run. And most of the rest I'd be spinning a web around to position himself better.
Idodoodletoo chapter 25 . 5/1
very good!
1210justinp chapter 7 . 3/28
I'm wondering about the comments who praised this fic. I can't even get this far without skimming the chapters.
Iceair chapter 2 . 2/9
I'm not liking this stumbling around, just feels like a waste of time for small misunderstandings during the story that doesn't really add anything to the story
Guest chapter 1 . 9/21/2023
MC already sounds like a disappointment...
Ellie.Cast4 chapter 25 . 7/29/2023
This has been such an exciting read! Im so bummed as it looks to be on a bit of a hiatus (hopefully not abandoned).
You did a phenomenal job of giving this SI such a fresh take on things, from the MC to the steps taken and outcomes of the battles, its been a splendid read. Who would have thought I would be rooting for the Freys?! The Freys?! You did that author, I am still a bit confused at how much I dig them.
Following on the chance your muse strikes and you return to this, I’d be eager to see where you take this. I suppose seeing him rally the other Kingdoms (sans Dorne because they know Aegon is a mummer’s dragon and just want Aryanne on the throne) and having folks declare preemptively for Dany would have him in a pretty good light for her arrival but I’m so curious about when he plans to drop the Jon bomb. And, AND he was specific in his declaration that no Riverland’s men would go North, lol. They’ll NEED people for the Whitewalkers, what then?!
Ugh, such a great read.
kirosyamcha chapter 25 . 7/13/2023
Kinda wished we got a Daenerys chapter before the story died :(
1,133 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »