Reviews for Guilty Rose |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() thank you for the chap No, but seriously, thank you. This is an amazingly well written fic. Keep it up! |
![]() ![]() ![]() Also, in the context of writing, the whole “no plan survives contact” thing only really works of the readers know the original plan, which we don’t. Why were Weiss and Cinder waiting outside? Additionally, what kind of plan to help Ilia escape from the fang would’ve required them to even be at the rally in the first place? If you want to take the next step, these are the questions you’ll need to learn to answer in the story without first being asked. A few lines of dialogue can do it: “We have an opportunity here, they don’t know Ilia wants out, we can catch them unaware if we attack them now” That’s not bulletproof (why does Ilia chafing sides matter in that context) but it’s far better than nothing. |
![]() ![]() ![]() Why the hell wouldn’t Blake just take ilia and run? Instead, she sent ilia to attack Ruby and then fucked right off, that makes no sense at all. It almost feels like you just wanted to have Ruby revert just so you could have her problems last longer. That’s not good writing, that’s just lazy. |
![]() ![]() ![]() Not much to say, you covered all the things I would say in the an, so say you are correct great work |
![]() ![]() ![]() this turned out really good. the interacions were good. are you going to have Rose meet Weisss father, i can only imagine how that is would to turn. as always your work is amazing and i cant wait for more. keep up the great work, hope RTX is fun for you. |
![]() ![]() ![]() Not killing Tyrian off now does make sense. In that he probably wouldn't leave himself open long enough for it to be an option. Now, biology isn't my strong suite but i feel like having a 6 inch kama blade go into your skull would kill you. Hopefully Ilia didn't get sliced and diced in the accidental-panic-murder-spree, cause that would be sad. Rose's mental state is going to be/already is bad enough as it is. All that aside. Tis nice to see updates. |
![]() ![]() ![]() Keep up the great writing. Also thought they were going to smuggle Ilia out, why bother pretending to fight Ruby and just sneak her out now? |
![]() ![]() ![]() ...ok and here I was thinking that Raven was the "normal" mom, but I was wrong, but hey great chapter! Now the kohai (Lydia) is safe, in a manner of speaking, her senpais can love her! Theres nothing that cant go wrong! *and suddenly a anvil falls next to me*Shit! Did I just summoned the Murphy Law!? Nah probably just my imagination right?...Right!? And when we will see some Yuri? *cough*CinderxWeiss*cough* sorry I think that I get the Flu XD |
![]() ![]() ![]() BOOM, BOOM, BOOM. With a side of BOOM. This is amazing. |
![]() ![]() ![]() Wonderfully good |
![]() ![]() ![]() The story just keeps getting better |
![]() ![]() Thank you for the chapter and have fun at RTX -Firecat21870 |
![]() ![]() ![]() That was awesome! |
![]() ![]() Wouldn't it be kinda funny if Raven opened a portal to the dorm and just popped in randomly jokes aside awesome chapter :D |
![]() ![]() ![]() Dun dun duuuun |