Reviews for Guilty Rose
AMW Riptide chapter 52 . 7/21/2022
Oh my god what I completely forgot about this fic lol I’m glad your back
hyabusabros chapter 52 . 7/21/2022
you know what, I'm happy your back and congrats on everything that's happened, I'm a writer on wattpad and have been going through something similar and kinda miss writing but I've just been waiting on rwby to release season 9 lol
M Rodriguez1 chapter 52 . 7/21/2022
Hey it good to hear form You I liked this story back then I understand the emotional part I think everyone went through crazy town there.
CrimsonMystic chapter 52 . 7/21/2022
Unbelievably hyped to get the notification for this fic. Life sometimes jostles us around (and sometimes outright suplexes us into a concrete floor) but all we can do is keep going as best we can.
Stay healthy, stay happy and I look forward to seeing more updates in the future!
Guest chapter 26 . 6/16/2022
fucking bullshit forgiving yang so easily, trust is something earn and once it's broken it's gone and don't fucking say it can be earn back cause the life ruby lived says otherwise
Guest chapter 25 . 6/16/2022
Yang broke that trust like a fucking dumbass
Guest chapter 8 . 6/15/2022
hurts don't it Blake? bitch
Guest chapter 7 . 6/15/2022
Blake is fucking annoying
Yummybuns chapter 51 . 2/18/2022
Pleaseeee continue!
DyyTheFirst chapter 51 . 2/14/2022
An excellent story! Spent the entire last week catching up on everything. The premise of the story is just so intriguing, setting Rose to be tortured for so many years, and ends the prologue with her escaping, yet not quite sure where to go, making the story's theme about recovery and healing rather than escaping. I really do feel bad for Rose in this story, it's just so hard to heal for her, and the damage has been so severe that she could never be the same again, but she's making progress, a step every day to finally recover. The rose harem part is pretty awesome as well! Didn't know this is the path you'd take but it makes sense, the Fallen White Petals part though is a bit, unbalanced I should say. Don't get me wrong, I love the pairing, but personally it feels very overshadowed by other aspects for the story. I'll try to elaborate, Cinder's role in the story starts to diminsih after the confession with Ozpin, her introduction and the original plan is for her to be the motivation and reason Rose escapes the Oni tribe, but other than that she doesn't have much chemistry with Rose. While Weiss's first kiss with Rose is to comfort her after Rose discovers Cinder is trying to infiltrate the CCT, Cinder's first kiss with Rose is to hide from the Ozpin and Ironwood; while Weiss is going to accompany Rose to meet Taiyang in future chapters, Cinder is staying behind; Weiss is the first person Rose liplocked with when she's drunk, while Cinder and Neo is the 2nd and 3rd respectively, and I noticed that Weiss actually had a lot more scenes with Rose compared to Cinder, and idk, but from the story I get the feeling Rose is more interested in Weiss than in Cinder. And now with Weiss crushing on Cinder as well, this whole relationship is going to be even more complicated. And not to mention if the three of them is to end up together happily ever after, how will Rose's other girlfriends Neo, Emerald, Blake and Ilia react? They can't possibly just quit that easily. But enough with the relationship issues, let's talk about other characters, you've written all of them on point, and all of them fit into the story really well, I'm very impressed by that. Even minor characters like Junior has good characterization. Though one thing I noticed is its a very character driven story, which isn't bad at all, but the pacing could be very slow sometimes and I can feel you worried a lot about how some characters would react to certain decisions. If some of the characters or scenes are too frustrating to write, I would suggest maybe cutting it off, the story can still stand with its many subplots and characters. You mentioned you receive every notification of the story, if you're still active on the site and just haven't found the time to update the story, don't worry, readers and fans will still stick by you no matter how long it takes. Take it slow if life is busy, writing can be damn hard sometimes and the stress of life can be too much, nobody can fault you for that. Those who do simply aren't worth your time. That said, I hope you have a great day!
darkonn243 chapter 32 . 12/26/2021
whiplash has been known to knock someone out
Cbrandes17 chapter 20 . 12/10/2021
God, I so wanted Raven to use her semblance while they were playing strip poker just to see the chaos it would've caused.
truefortune chapter 1 . 11/16/2021
So is the fic dead or writer block? Hope it’s the later cause I don’t seem to know a lot of ruby/harems with cinder in it, or ilia.
Quickened chapter 28 . 9/20/2021
Haven’t seen team JNPR is chapters!
Quickened chapter 27 . 9/20/2021
When ‘Nope’ runs in the family…
657 | « Prev Page 1 .. 2 3 4 5 6 7 14 .. Last Next »