Reviews for Maggie of Manhattan
Quinn Taxon chapter 17 . 1/1
It's almost disturbing how much you deviate from the original storyline/character development. That there is tension between Derek and Maggie here- yes- that was obvious. But the fight between the two one on one- and how ragingly hateful Derek became and blood spurting- ohhh that was wonderfully upsetting and a stab in the heart to all who support the Derek/Maggie ship. Which aren't THAT many- many wanted Brooklyn and Mags to get together and you satisfy that. Sevarius post-mortem summary of Derek's state of mind and how easy he would be to manipulate was on point. I love that they're trying to integrate Madison into the clan- that's bound to spark more conflict with Pride and Thailog and Xanatos.
Vanessa Masters chapter 23 . 12/10/2024
I knew Anna would lose those babies. Something bad would happen, and cranley is put under house arrest more less.

Sucks.

But Lexington shined with that virus, and Xanatos may realize he's in over his head with the pride

Owen certainly doesn't approve and they agree frank needs gone

But higurashhsi working with Thailog, does David know, or not? Hrrrrm.

.now. lol David and Goliath.

Well, a intense chapter.

And Maggie takes home a little cloned sister in a way.
OMAC001 chapter 23 . 12/8/2024
Thailog's moving his pieces into place...
D the Stampede chapter 17 . 12/8/2024
Hey, I'm more a reader than a reviewer, but I'm loving your story here. Moreover, to me anyway, is that this feels like a real what if? type of storyline for Gargoyles. Anyways, keep up the good work, happy holidays 2024 if I don't write another review to you before 2025 and all that.
RonaldM40196867 chapter 23 . 12/8/2024
Xanatos loves his schemes.

More fighting please.
OMAC001 chapter 22 . 11/13/2024
Looks like the fight between the Clan and Pack is heating back up!
RonaldM40196867 chapter 22 . 11/13/2024
Derek could be important later.

Very cute.
Vanessa Masters chapter 21 . 11/9/2024
"Can I say something?" Madison asked, standing up.

"Of course, lass," Hudson said.

"This Maza guy was pretty scary when I met him, but it sounds like he was used just like Radar used me. I was pretty convinced I had to be with Radar because no one would have me after becoming… this. But you guys reached out to me, and it's a whole different world to what I had before. I know it's not the same. You reached out to Derek and he lashed out at you, but I like to think people can do wrong, even bad stuff, but still not be just horrible. I'm sorry, I'm just rambling, aren't I?" Madison looked down.

Maggie walked over to her and reached out, almost touching the smaller Chimera's chin, prompting her to tilt her head up and let Maggie touch her chin, and delicately point her face up to hers.

"We Chimeras have been through a lot, haven't we?" Maggie said. "Until you came along, I was getting used to seeing all others of my kind as enemies." She looked back to the others. "I think we should go with Lexington's plan. I'm not sure it's what Goliath would want, but I don't think we can fully trust them just yet. But it would be even worse to just give them half-heated aid after wanting just this to happen."

"Well, if Lex doesn't mind leasing out his project, I don't see any problem," Broadway said, shrugging.

"I'm with you," Brooklyn said to Maggie.

"Do they have a television down there? They'll be needing that," Hudson mused.

Madison smiled, and Maggie patted her head, returning it.

-

Wise words Madison.

Sweet girl.

, Maggie is being reasonable given what Derek did.

And he's realistic, knows to keep his distance, Mayne try to make amends, but not push it.

Guess he learned his lesson.

Oh if only Elisa was there to see him come back from Xanatos
Vanessa Masters chapter 20 . 11/9/2024
Ha, oh you think you'll be a leader, or in control, or you'll start a new race?

If this follows the comic.

Well, I doubt that.

Still, I'm happy with Maggie and Brooklyn.

Though he put himself there, I'm feeling for Derek.
Vanessa Masters chapter 19 . 11/7/2024
"You realize they were fleeing for their lives?" Goliath pointed out.

"What of it? Avalon is the home of our kind; it was our right to turn away those who seek entry."

"Would you not be angered if one demanded entrance to your home, and after being refused forced their way in?"

"Did it ever occur to you to negotiate?" Goliath asked. Only the golden-haired sister didn't seem a bit surprised at his question. "Time passes differently on Avalon. A hundred years of refuge you could have offered with ease. Time enough for Constantine and any other foes to perish."

The blonde smiled at him, while the dark-haired one glared.

"We had no right to admit anyone. Oberon commanded us to guard the way, to guard Avalon in his absence."

"Guard, not bar, perhaps? A guard does not just ward away intruders, they also open the way in peace. Perhaps your father wanted you to understand the spirit behind his laws rather than just blind obedience when he set you your task." Goliath pressed. "So, is that all? It tells me a bit of you and Oberon, and your motivation. But there's more, isn't there? You claim now to have helped me, even as you sought revenge on Magus. Yet you act as if you are pleased Magus died in peace?"

"The time is not yet for more answers," they said together, returning to identical expressions.

Goliath frowned, but guessed he would get no more answers from them. "The clan here has no love for you. Magus was one of them; if I ask them to lock you away, you will remain bound for ages."

"You know well that even bound, our kind are perilous."

"Such coldness is not in your nature, even to your enemies."

"What is time to an immortal?"

"I am willing to free you with conditions," Goliath admitted.

"Go on."

-

Huh, so they're are Oberon's own daughters?

is right about the guard and spirit of the order thing.

Cool.
Vanessa Masters chapter 18 . 11/7/2024
Angela and the others!

Oh, Alexis better watch himself, or he'll meet a ugly end.
Vanessa Masters chapter 17 . 11/7/2024
"Step aside lads, let me have proper look at her," he commanded, strolling forward. They obeyed, their petty jovial argument on what she should be shown first suspended. They'd seen each other at the battle, of course, but it was a whole different thing when you could take a good proper look.

"Hmm, a skinny one you brought us, Maggie. If we were the monsters the rumors say, I'd be annoyed at what a lousy meal she'd make," Hudson joked, catching the girl's eye.

"I'd say, Broadway could eat her up himself and still want Chinese food," Lex quipped.

"Now don't be hasty, maybe a side of fries, a bottle of ketchup."

"Don't be absurd, she's clearly meant for mustard," Broadway took part after affecting offense for a moment. The girl's eyes went wide, but looking to Maggie she saw the Chimera woman roll her eyes, and any lingering fear seemed to slip away as the girl giggled into her hand.

-

Lol

Oh yeah, heres hoping if Santa Claus is real, he's all he's hyped up as golly...sickness he's obviously one of Oberon children.

Anna, your control Is a fragile illusion, wait for it to break.
Vanessa Masters chapter 16 . 11/7/2024
Poor Bobbi.

And poor niobe.

She's not moronic, she's lost someone she loved. Not that Higurashi would understand.

Oh, avalon arc and Xanatos doesn't like the ides of bigger powers.
Vanessa Masters chapter 15 . 11/7/2024
"When we thought Hudson was dead, my head was full of regrets, things I didn't say to him, or ask him. More regrets than I would have guessed. Funny, after the massacre, you'd think I could take it in stride. Right?"

Maggie shook her head, the beautiful lion woman frowning.

"Not funny at all."

"Yeah, but anyway. It got me thinking about other regrets I'd have. Things I would have wished if it had been me instead of Hudson… Maggie, would you like to go on a date?" Brooklyn asked.

"…Brooklyn,"

"If the answer's no, fine, I know you want to be human again someday. But I had to ask. I thought after the rooftop we had something going, but it doesn't seem to have gone anywhere. So, did I read it wrong or am I supposed to do something? Er, you can sleep on it, well, I guess, I will…"

"Okay. Did you have anything in mind?" Maggie asked, setting another dry cup down. She was staring at the floor.

"Sorry, what?"

"She said yes, idiot! Keep going!" Broadway yelled from out of sight. Then there was a pained sound as someone smacked him.

"Good night, lass," Hudson chuckled.

"…Let's talk details tomorrow?" Brooklyn said.

"Yeah, sounds good," Maggie gulped, licking her lips. Brooklyn made his way to the stairs then stopped after a few steps upward.

"By the way, I like the new jewelry. You look real pretty with it. Not that you weren't pretty before, but well… I'm going to go get ready for dawn," Brooklyn said, before beating a hasty retreat up the stairs. Maggie laughed a little under her breath and adjusted her circlet. Then the lion woman thoughtfully picked up a clean plate and looked at her reflection in the ceramic, thoughtfully brushing at her mane idly with her claws.

-

Eeeeee, I'm squealing.

I love it.

Omg you had Brooklyn catch Maggie and end up with his face in her boobs, marvelous. Lmao.

And Maggie down, glad she's second in command.

Oh yikes that Caroline.

Does this follow the comics, cause how is she and Anne gonna react if the 'kits' are born human looking? O.o

But Maggie, finds jewelry, money and magic items.
Vanessa Masters chapter 14 . 10/25/2024
"Oh my God. You really didn't see this coming, did you? Not at all? Did you think you'd get a pat on the back and a 'welcome to the Pride' after looking down on us? After stringing Derek along, taking any chance to feel up our men, calling it an exam, and lying to the other patients about their chances of survival? At least Xanatos is generous and polite; so long as we're good pawns, he'll take care of us. But you… I for one have wanted to kick your ass since you kept snatching my drinks away or ordering people I don't know to push me places, rubbing my helplessness in my face. Well, you're in the Pride, but while I'm in charge of the women here, you're on the bottom. And rest assured, you try anything with my Greek or Klaus, me and Caroline will nail those ears of yours to the wall. Welcome to the bottom on the pecking order, Doc! We'll be sure to wipe our feet on you on the way out," Anna roared, releasing Cranley's wrists, only to then grab the neck of her leotard. She ripped the cloth as Cranley struggled out from under the knee, Anna shifting her weight.

After a brief struggle and the sound of tearing cloth, the naked lynx Chimera raced down the corridor on all fours, slipping in the turn to smack against the wall before disappearing around the corner.

Breathing hard, Anna smiled, opening her fists and letting the pieces of the Doc's leotard fall to the floor. Catching her breath, she turned her face to the security camera and gave it a two-fingered salute.

-

I really don't likeCaroline, or anne, really hope something happens to them.

I can't deny, they aren't written to be liked.

And Maggie seems to be progressing well.

And look at lex, finding a back up place, just in case.
140 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »