|Reviews for Crime and Punishment|
| Guest chapter 28 . 9/21
I'm so sad it has been so long. I love this story so much and can't believe its been 2 yrs! Please, please come back. This story is way too good to not finish.
| Liseyloo123 chapter 28 . 9/20
I have absolutely loved this story, I have felt every emotion possible with this story, from crying tears of hurt and sorrow for harry, to crying tears of laughter over Mrs applewhaite. You have truly captured snapes character and I feel a realistic reaction to everything. I really do hope you can get round to finishing but understand life gets in the way and it has been a a while since you last updated. I can honestly say this has become a favourite of mine and I binged these 28 chapters in a matter of 3 nights. Thankyou for a moving and brilliant read!
| Amanda Pall chapter 28 . 8/26
Amazing Amazing story! I hvae loved all your stories but this is my favorite. But what a place to stop! WE NEED MORE! i have to say one of the greatest scenes was the truth serum. This story has made me cry so often. Really stunning writing, excellent dialogue, descriptive and moving passages please keep it up!
| Jamie257 chapter 28 . 8/25
Continuation please Your fanfic is really good
| Ellaquill chapter 4 . 8/21
“Like death and taxes, you can be certain that I will finish my stories,” she says…
| hskahfkakc chapter 28 . 8/12
hello i love this story so far and i went to click on the next chapter button, was horrified to find none there, checked when this was last updated and was once again horrified because the date is from almost 3 years ago
thank you for your effort, grab a snack and some water when u see this :)
P.S.: PLEASE come back to finish this if you're up to it I BEG YOU
| xxxLeanniexxx chapter 28 . 7/23
Spent all Sunday reading this- amazing story
| merseacow chapter 28 . 7/13
Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful story with us all-I've loved every single chapter, even the ones that made me cry. It was such a joy to read, and I'm grateful to have had the privilege.
I hope you're happy and healthy!
| Just William chapter 28 . 5/24
Hast this story been abandoned?
| AspergianStoryteller chapter 16 . 5/3
Considering that some parents are screwed-up enough to destroy their kid's possessions, and how Snape used to treat Harry, the fear's legit.
| Dumbledore-The-Phoenix chapter 28 . 4/25
my head-canon is that Tillie cut their electricity because she suspected they were wizards and wanted to catch them in the act lol
| HarryPotter4evah chapter 28 . 4/10
Love this story so much. And so very sad its been so long since the last update. Will you update soon or are you done with this story?
| rowenasheir chapter 27 . 4/6
Harry seems to expect adults to act responsibly even though he says and acts as if he doessn't ttrust them. Then he is hurt when they don't!
Remus was James' friend/brother-in-arms but doesn't try to see Harry at all and when he does, he makes no attempt create a relationship with him. he actually would'nt have anything to do with Harry at all if AD hadn't made him DADA teacher when SB escaped Azkaban. I wouldn't trust him if i was Harry. Now he wants to act like he has been involved in Harry's upbringing, reprimand, dictate and admonish as if has the right!
SOB was a spoilt, entitled brat as a teenager and Azkaban did him no favours. He dumped Harry as a baby on the nearest 'adult' (one that can't even do magic in a magic world) just on his word to chase after Peter for revenge. The baby was hurt, bleeding and he was standing in front of the blown up house and his response wasn't to make sure he was caed for but to pass responsibilty onto anyone else. And he still allows AD to dictate Harry's life; where he lives, where and when he is allowed to do anything.
Alus Dumbledore is an abuse enabler; heaven forbid that he get his own hands dirty. The American have a saying, plausible deniablity. Then, he still sends children back into abusive homes. He encourages descent, division and hatred between the Houses at Hogwarts that poisons the whole society, punishing the righteous and rewards wrong doing and encouranges bullying. There is no accountablity or consequences to reach moral values at all. Is he conducting a social experient at Hogwarts? The narcissit shouldn't be allowed within mile of any children.
Snapes needs a mind healer. He an abused and bullied child that has become the bully and abuser. In this story he has realised he was wrong when he couldn't deny the evidence anymore. Now he is trying to make up for it. he shouldn't be allowed to parent Harry.
But when AD couldn't find any way to leave Harry with his current abusers. the Durleys, who he had forced to take HP originally; he had to find the next best thing and force Snape to take the child. Another person who disliked/loathed/hated Harry, the son of the person who bullied him and who he liked to emotionally and verbally abuse in return. You can't tell me that he isn't busy with a social experiement, trying slightly different variable each time trying to get a favourable result. (TMR, then SS and now HP and who knows how may faliures where the child broke, committed suicide or was killed by their abusers)
| CityGirl7768 chapter 1 . 3/13
Just read this story. I see it has been quite a while since its been updated. but no note of abandon status so I hope you come back. I would love to see this story continued. This story is really great.
| Guest chapter 28 . 3/10
It's been so long. Please, please don't abandon this story. It's one of my absolute favorites. I'll be crushed if you don't finish it.