|Reviews for Annals of Arithmancy|
| Guest chapter 24 . 11/11
I was keeping this story for when I wanted new inspiration. I read (I devoured) both stories about the Aritmanther and enjoyed them tremendously. And then this one was a bit of a surprised. Specially because I’m the age of the older children, Sasha, Columba, Marcus…
And then you wrote about 2020 and I was certain that you’ll make it so that the magic world would help the muggle one with COVID and reveal itself sooner and from a very positive point of view, like these great helpers with their breakthrough advances… but then I realised that you had written it in 2019 and it was impossible to know the future.
I like your ending. It’s just not as impressive as the one I proposed to myself in retrospective.
I think I’ve missed the original goal of this email, which is to compliment you on your amazing world building abilities and to thank you for all the knowledge you’ve poured into your story. As stated before, I’ve enjoyed them tremendously.
Duke of owlington
| Spellflame chapter 24 . 8/24
Is there anyone who took this on?
| nikoladd chapter 16 . 8/22
Ha-Ha-Ha movie night with The Thing on a station in Antarctica. This movie came out when I was a 9y old kid. A friend of mine, had seen it, and recounted it to me. He went to the movie theater with his much older sister. I had nightmares for quite a while back then. I watched the movie myself about ten years later and it was still unsettling enough. Apparently my friend did a good job at recounting the story in great detail, hence my nightmares.
| The cat with blue eyes chapter 24 . 7/13
a very nice ending to this trilogy! i really liked the fact that you took technilogy into account and how that will force their hand
| odonnellzoo99 chapter 24 . 7/3
I'm glad that I finally remembered to come back and finish reading the series.
| odonnellzoo99 chapter 10 . 7/1
I was wondering when that was going to happen.
| buckeyecapsfan19 chapter 21 . 6/27
I think muggles would win a major wizard-muggle conflict because the way muggles wage war has a two-hundred year head-start on wizards. How would wizards counter combined arms, fire and maneuver, "shoot-and-scoot" artillery, counter-battery fires, laser and GPS guided weapons (and laser and GPS guided *artillery*), Tomahawks launched from 1,000 miles away with the precision to hit a particular corner of a target building. The scene you wrote in Lady Archimedes about Hermione and friends traveling under the Great Lake? SEALs and other Tier 1 special operators have done that for decades, with closed-circuit rebreathers and Seal Delivery Vehicles. If Hermione had a squadron of A-10s, the Battle of Hogwarts would have been hours shorter (Massed armies on the field versus a 4,000 rounds per minute gatling gun? Slaughter on the Death Eater side). I know the Reddit threads you speak of, and I've held back from responding, because, well, Reddit.
| Fick Chick chapter 24 . 6/5
I've really enjoyed this series. It got a bit dry during the heavy math sections but I just skimmed though anything over my head. I still wonder what's might happen next and can just see muggles blaming magicals for COVID or mad cow or whatever.
| Fick Chick chapter 17 . 6/4
What about Dobby & Sonya's child?
| Potter Abducted by Penguins chapter 24 . 5/20
Do you plan on a 4th book? It would be great to read how the repeal of the Statute of Secrecy would affect the world.
| PirateGypsieQueen chapter 24 . 4/27
Brilliant series, great characteristics yet the ending seemed some what forced.
That said I enjoyed the tech aspects as much as the world building.
It got a bit confusing listing Marcus Vector as Hermione's kid and I'll admit I half expected you to kill off Septima in an attack for Hermione to go ape.
I think my favourite part was were Hermione quotes The Doctor and even vaguely resembles umm Her.
Looking forward to reading more of your fics
| smilejul chapter 24 . 4/8
AHHHHHHH... ok just read all 3 parts and when you can I need a part 4 wouldn't mind you coming back to this world and continuing it.. really good writing style. HATED the ending though.
| Rravan2002 chapter 24 . 2/10
Very bittersweet, and a satisfying end. Almost wish there was more haha. A lovely story that kept me coming back to it over and over throught the trilogy. Thank you for the experience.
| rmcsquared chapter 24 . 1/7
Loved the story, thank you so much for writing. As someone who very much identified with Hermione's personality in canon (I used to be a horrendous know it all) and as someone who has a master's in physics, I just loved this series, and really identified with how Hermione grew and thoroughly enjoyed the interaction between the maths and magic. You have created a masterful universe which has been thoroughly enjoyable to partake in.
My only issue is that in the time between finishing Lady Archimedes and starting this I had a great idea for a fic based on Astoria's illness only to find you covered it almost the same in this story. Great minds think a like. it took a bit of the gloss off my idea but I will still slowly work on it.
| Piletorn chapter 24 . 9/21/2022
Noooo.. I’m done and I want to know what happened next xD