Reviews for The Archmage of Arda |
---|
DeathWing-GPV chapter 9 . 9/4 This was a truly wonderful story to behold. I know that I am late to it's creation, but I hope to see a sequel sometime. |
angel.salas5682 chapter 9 . 7/27 It was truly beautiful, it reminded me of Middle Earth and especially Harry's character. I also liked the character development. Now I wonder if you brought Arwen with Harry to your world and made him your company. It would be interesting to see a story about the "traveler." lonely" translated from Spanish to English if it is not understood |
LittleBoyDeath chapter 9 . 7/13 Please continue! |
Hank1967 chapter 9 . 6/29 A very enjoyable tale! I do hope you do not leave the fair Arwen and the valiant Harry to their dreary fates... After all, it's your fault! ;-) Please gift us a sequel soon! |
tearsofthings chapter 3 . 6/28 I love the story itself and the characters but I feel like the thing that ruins it, and the reason it doesn't have more favs is all this prophecy stuff. All these people telling Harry he is going to do this and going to do that, or to save this or save them. It removes autonomy from him. Like reading the last few pages of a book, it ruins the journey. I don't believe LotR magic even really has prophecy on that level. Magic is much more subtle, and the whole point of LotR is that it's an "everchanging song" written by Eru Ilúvatar. There is a reason prophecy came out so late in the Harry Potter books, because it would have spoiled the end. |
l30rusty chapter 4 . 6/16 i enjoy the story but ya kinda made harry way way way way way over powered asin to a ridiculously insane scale |
fraewyn chapter 9 . 6/7 Loved it! |
AQuestionWhy chapter 9 . 6/7 This was a really good one, I liked this more than the usual Tolkien-HP crossover, because it wasn’t about Harry fixing the existing plots of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, but establishing himself as a fixture of the world. Look forward to a sequel, if you ever post it but even if you don’t, I’ve enjoyed this immensely and I’m glad to have found this |
AlexiRomanoff1 chapter 9 . 5/14 3rd time ive read this, still good, it tickles the lotr feelings in m brain. |
BRoberts1353 chapter 2 . 5/13 There aren't any unicorns in Middle Eartgh |
VincentFS chapter 1 . 5/6 While the fight scene mentioned in my previous review was lame, you most definitely captured the wonders of Middle Earth through your writing. I binged the whole story in one sitting due to pure excitement. I am genuinely sad that the sequel mentioned on your page will never be published here. Incredible writing, mate. I have no words to describe how amazing this story is. |
VincentFS chapter 2 . 5/6 The fight scene is lame as fuck. “Take that!” “And that!” Seriously? |
Nomnom345 chapter 5 . 4/13 I feel like you took all the potential the story had with all the intriguing joy and ripped it apart in one chapter. We definitely not recommend this story after that. |
Regnorash chapter 1 . 4/13 This story is amazing. Too bad there is no sequel. |
fallenangel8635 chapter 9 . 2/18 Good read thank you |