Splendid. It's so rare to see a completed HP fanfic these days. It's clear that you planned the whole story well and it come along seamlessly; the prose improved a lot as the chapters progressed. You succeeded in making me feel part of the magical LOTR universe. Congratulations! I would love to read a sequel, if you decide to post one day.

This is a short but masterful work. I have long been ignoring fics below a certain length. This work has thoroughly convinced me of my error, and awakened a craving for LotR once more. Thanks author.

what a great story! is the sequel being worked on still, or is it dead? I hope to read more from you!

love your story. loved your craft.

10/10 for me

please, is there a sequel in the works?

This story is great. The stories and themes flow beautifully. You definitely succeeded in capturing a little bit of that tolkin magic. can't wait for the sequel. Hope you post it soon.

So to keep his wife alive longer than her natural human lifespan, he leaves her to study alchemy. Makes sense to me.

holy shit, i am utterly speechless. that was an absolutely amazing story and i really hope you are doing well and that they sequel comes out some time soon. thank you so much.

Even though the changes to his physical appearance were already immeasurable, you nevertheless chose to present him a hat filled with every book in the Hogwarts library. Do you not feel that you overdid it?

Wow. Amazing. I'm speechless at how well you have told a tale that is true to both mythos and brings such highs and lows that tears fall without care. Really a treasure to read. thank you.

Incredible story and well written.
I hope the sequel comes out soon.

Absolutely amazing story, without the promised sequel feels like a wip however. Come on u cant leave it like that. As a standalone story thats well written, then just banged a rushed epilogue on the end. Such a real shame.

will there be a story about professor galad? i would love to read more of this as a continuation to this well written story i hope to read more of it when and if you make it let me know please!

This is an amazing story! I wish there was a sequel, I'm very interested in how you write and your story telling. I will be following with the hope you come back!