Reviews for What If? |
---|
soccermom101113 chapter 43 . 10/30 Thanks for sharing. Wasn't sure I would like it without Bella/Edward. I was amazing! |
Guest chapter 43 . 10/19 Loved the ending, it was filled with love and humor. I agree that SMeyer did Leah wrong. Like I stated earlier she was made to be the villain in that stupid triangle, or whatever you want to call it, with Sam and Emily. Great writing! I'm going to start reading your story on Leah now. Thank you for the great story! |
Guest chapter 41 . 10/19 I loved the twist! Edward saying he tricked Bella into kissing him that she loved him too. She told him she loved Jacob more. He said the whole King Solomon line than he said he'd never bother her again. I loved it! Great writing! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 40 . 10/19 Rosalie had the safest story on turning than the rest of the Cullens. I felt for her even when her vanity and shallowness irked me. Great job getting her story in and with a unique twist to it. I loved it! Great writing! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 39 . 10/19 Not surprised that Jessica reacted to Mike's death like she did because she had feelings for him, unlike Victoria. Jacob still got injured by a newborn but at least he has Bella. Great writing! I loved it! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 38 . 10/19 Edward was a manipulative ass instead of Jacob. Edward was meant to be one too. Great writing! I loved it! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 37 . 10/19 The best part about the tent scene was that unlike in canon, Bella was with Jacob, not Edward. Great writing! I loved it! Thanks again. |
Guest chapter 36 . 10/19 Chief Jacob! I love it! Great writing! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 35 . 10/19 I'm so happy Bella realized that Edward was able to convince her of anything and could get her to do anything and that made him dangerous. Jacob is real and is in love with her. I'm glad she realizes they're meant to be together. I loved that you included Raven Tales, I love those! Raven was always taking easy copycat shortcuts and not being true to himself. Great writing! I loved it! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 31 . 10/19 Jasper is an empath that feels emotions, so why would he join the Confederacy that started because the didn't like the fact that the North was upset because they owned slaves after reading the book, Uncle Tom's Cabin? Jasper had to have felt their emotions from being owned and in some cases abused. SMeyer never explained that , I'm glad you did. Great writing! I loved it! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 29 . 10/19 It sounded like Eric Yorkie became a vampire too, not surprised. Great writing! I loved it! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 28 . 10/19 Hot and bothered! |
Guest chapter 27 . 10/19 I'm not surprised they hide in a rain forest on a reservation, I had a feeling that's where they hid. Except for Victoria. I think she's probably elsewhere. Great writing! I love it! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 26 . 10/19 I have read the Quileute Creation Orgin legend multiple times, too bad you didn't find a way to use it. I found SMeyer 's version in Eclipse highly offensive and I'm not Quileute. Reading about how Mormons in the past had a racial bias against Native Americans makes me wonder if she has a racial bias against them. Heck, Taha Aki's third wife saved the tribe and she's called the third wife, I don't believe it's because they forgot her name over time. I believe she didn't find her worthy of a name beyond the third wife. Great writing! I loved it, despite not being able to use the Creation Orgin legend! Thank you! |
Guest chapter 25 . 10/19 Newborn army made up of Bella's friends to destroy her and the pack, Victoria is more twisted in this than in canon, SMeyer could have learned a few things from you on writing Victoria's character for Eclipse. Great writing! I loved it! Thank you! |