|Reviews for Memories of a Peredhil|
| Inspector Minkey chapter 1 . 6/21/2004
This is a beautiful story (*sniff!*)! As a matter of fact, Elvira, you inspired me to start posting myself. Thanks for that! You have a lovely writing style: evocative of the original works. Keep writing!
| degustaciones chapter 1 . 8/29/2003
Your timeline is seriously screwed, you know, because Estel was born almost five hundred years after Celebrian left, not half a measly century. Also, you can gank from poems if you want, but CREDIT them, will you?
| Sphinx chapter 1 . 5/28/2003
Very nice. I liked this not only as a Elrond/Celebrian fan but also a diehard angst freak. Just one thing, though. Celebrian's name is related to Celeborn's. And since he's silver haired, I would also think that she is silver haired, and not golden, like Galadriel. Just gives her name more meaning! Ignore it, if you like!
| Arabella Thorne chapter 1 . 5/28/2003
A lovely lovely tale..so very sweet..and I think the Browning poem was just perfect. Good job! (And I think celebrian would have liked Estel too)
| ArwenGranger chapter 1 . 5/28/2003
Ahh how sweet.