Reviews for A Red Rose in the Blue Wind
Guest chapter 34 . 12/12
To Farmer A, stop being such a killjoy. And get over yourself. If you don't like how the author is handling the RWBY characters in a way that no one does and and actually explores their character flaws, then you need to go find another story that satisfies your preferences.
Guest chapter 34 . 12/12
Someone sure is ignorant of the situation in the reviews.
Chaos Bringer chapter 1 . 12/11
I can see The Chaos emeralds being able to empower the relics allowing for them to be far stronger than in canon and removing their limitations like allowing for 9 wishes from the relic of knowledge or removing the need for blueprints for the relic of creation.
Farmer A chapter 34 . 12/12
Ruby would NOT be defending Jaune for what he said to Qrow about Summer.

What the actual heck?
Guest chapter 36 . 12/8
When you bring Penny back you could make her have a trauma with Metal Sonic because he literally dismantled her in the most brutal way possible and I think Ruby too since she saw Penny die in his hands and even worse with her own weapon being used to kill her. For me this would bring more depth to the story like the characters would be scared when they meet Metal Sonic again especially Penny where she practically "died" in his hands and there would be a kind of trigger where she would run away from Metal having vivid memories of his death passing through her head but also another character who could develop a trauma with Metal Sonic would be Oscar since he is the reincarnation of Ozpin and I don't know if he will have memories or like dreams of him being killed with his heart pierced I don't remember if in the main series if he will have dreams with Ozpin's memories since I don't remember much of the series
phamgiadai609 chapter 36 . 12/8
im so excited for the possibility of other characters appearing
tangle and whisper in Mistral
meeting with team sonic
team Chaotix landing in Menagerie
the best dectives helping out Blake with this mystery
SilverBalze could end up in Atlas
meeting with Tails and Weiss
Cream and Gemerl in Vacuo
meeting with the rest of them
The Loud Person chapter 2 . 12/7
I would like to apologize for my behaviour. I just got really irritated with the constant accusations and people bringing up character bashing so many times it was just exhausting to see and it should just stop. But I did not act in a professional manner at all.

So I am sorry for blowing things out of proportion and causing this to happen. I did not mean for any of this to occur.
Guest chapter 36 . 12/7
Ignore the hater.
Godo chapter 36 . 12/7
Tense chapter, heartbreaking, especially with Qrow. Unfortunate, but this is what happen when Misunderstandings go on for too long. Same with unneeded grudges. I mean I can understand the conflict that Qrow and Sonic and his friends have. But the latter wants to get over it and are willing to let bygones be bygones. Unfortunately Qrow is prolonging it. I understand that he feels that Sonic may have dragged his nieces to the war, but honestly Ruby and Yang were going to be involved anyway considering how Salem has been killing off Silver Eyed Warriors for years, Ruby being one, and Yang being the older sister would be there for the former.

And it's not helped with how Qrow didn't help his case when he called Yang Raven. I mean yeah his trauma along with bitterness towards his sister is there, but he ended up projecting it on Yang. Of course you say that Yang was the one lost herself in her rage that it ended up reminding Qrow of Raven and Yang has been bottling up her insecurities for so long that she ended lashing out. Honestly it's no one's fault. It's just how it is when things get so tense and emotional, it's hard for anyone to be rational.

But again, Qrow isn't helping his case considering how he keeps brushing off Sonic and his friends even they try to lend him a hand and Knuckles being the one to stop Yang from attacking her uncle. What makes this more heartbreaking is that Qrow is going to react far worse when the truth about Ozpin comes out. I mean years of being loyal to the guy who pretty much is your father figure, only find out that he was being given false hopes in the war that he had fought so hard in is going break a man's faith.

So yeah, Qrow is going to have a terrible time picking himself back up. Some of things are his fault, others being Ozpin who pretty much influenced him on the whole keeping secret things that doesn't go so well with others.
Guest chapter 1 . 12/6
Iron117Prime, I apologize on behalf of everyone in this review section, and hope you don't let anything said here negatively affect how you write your story. You're stories good, it just needs some work here or there. But, please don't let everyone here yelling at each other deter you from making your story how you wanna make it.
Anon chapter 36 . 12/6
Everyone shut the hell up, and take your arguments and toxic bullshit somewhere else. Let's leave this review section argument free, for the sake of the author at least
VV chapter 36 . 12/6
Will we see JNPR's side in this arc? Cause, Ren doesn't closure for his past yet.
fruitspunchsamurai-987 chapter 18 . 12/6
Toxic fandoms, it's always toxic fandoms that suck the fun out of reading a story. So sad that this is the life we have to put up with.
Farmer A chapter 35 . 12/6
Go right ahead and hate on me: it still doesn't change the fact that I think the author is hating on Qrow and Ozpin for no valid reason- which he has been proven of doing on other forums.

Qrow and Ozpin aren't even my favorite characters- but I also get REALLY sick of people hating on them in their works, especially considering other characters get white-washed to make them look worse.
Annoyed Anon chapter 36 . 12/6
Welcome to the modern day, where people forget how to give actual constructive criticism, and be respectful to one another, because everyone gets too emotionally invested in their opinions, and think they can speak to anyone however they want...
2,168 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »