Reviews for A Fake Familiar Reborn
Breakerp16 chapter 1 . 1/14/2023
I like that this story still lives in some way, but there are many issues that need to be addressed.

The way you write vs the copied and pasted parts are jarring. When rewriting something, unless you have the exact same writing style, I recommend actually re-writing everything instead of copy pasting parts of the original text. Some of the original bits also make less sense now that the context has changed.

There are continuity issues (and it's only chapter 1!) things happen but are not explained or glossed over (Archer falling through the roof and nobody fixing it.)

I've seen so misused expressions "Threw them out of the loop" this means excluding from something while you mean "Threw them for a loop" which means confused them.

Archer acting out of character and commenting on falling through the roof. Him say "ugh, not again" makes no sense has he has been through countless timelines and would be used to being summoned is such a way, albeit by Rin and not Rias.

Overall, this fic feels like a major drop in quality compared to the original. I'll probably come down to this down the line since I might be biased from re-read A Fake Familiar since I though there was a new chapter.

Overall I'm disappointed, but then again, I've never seen an adopted fic work. They always get abandoned or the new author changes things and it doesn't work or any amount of other problems.
PSYCongroo chapter 1 . 1/13/2023
Great, I can't wait to see what happens next.
Thanks for the chapter.
Morregen chapter 1 . 1/13/2023
Really good chapter and idea. I enjoyed it! :)

I look forward to the next chapter. Already quite addictive to read! :3
PasiveNox chapter 1 . 1/13/2023
Great chapter and start
Mugen no Tenma chapter 1 . 1/13/2023
Awesome! I'm glad this story got reborn.
Guest chapter 1 . 1/13/2023
I can't thank you enough! You've really made my day. Thanks so much for continuing one of my favorite Fate x DxD fics!
pltrgst chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
it's still an info dump
Mythic Imagination chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
A nice edit of the chapter. I’m very grateful you accepted to adopt the story from Paragon of Awesomeness. It would be a real bummer to see such a fantastic story being abandoned. I’m eager to see the future chapters.
KamenRider Caucasus chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
Thank you for taking up writing this story you have done a wonderful job
Guest chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
I am willing to bet Emiya is seeing this as a perfect chance to earn a vacation from being a counter guardian despite just being a small piece or a copy of the original. I can't wait see if this story will be better than the original.
negi83 chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
The resuscitation of stories is a noble and honorable thing, and generally a good thing. I'm waiting for "The Sword of the Veil" to be resurrected someday.
The embodiment of Weirdness chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
This story is going to be a really great one I'm sure. Can't wait to see EMIYA reacting to Kiba's Sacred Gear, or his encounter with the dragon Emperors and Hero Faction as well as the Excalibur fragments.

If he wasn't a Ghost, he'd have died of a seizure from all the headaches he'd have from how DxD functions.
Paxloria chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
I wish you luck with continuing the story that other person started.

I noticed that you chose to make some changes to how the beginning started versus the (MUCH BETTER & more thought-out) original version.

You did better at giving a reason on why Rias got a Command Seal, but chose to change things so that Archer wouldn't be summoned at his best and basically copied how it went with Rin in FATE/STAY NIGHT.

There IS an error (no-doubt caused by getting too carried away with changes & getting distracted) caused by Archer falling through the roof like that.
There should have been more of a reaction (or at least SOME kind of reaction) when Archer pointed that out.
Also, you have the Devils re-arranging the room & putting the furnature back in place BUT forgot to write that the Devils FIRST used magic to fix the damage caused by Archer's fall before doing those things.
I also notice chat Archer is not asking any questions about the Grail.
Saif Omar chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
One of my most favourite authors writing a crossover about two of my most favourite fandoms? Sign me the fuck up! I am SOOOOO looking forward to what this story entails considering how well you wrote EMIYA in your other stories.
Archer headass chapter 1 . 1/12/2023
amazing I just binged your snafu dxd story in 3 days and now you are doing this one with my favourite series and character.
1,469 | « Prev Page 1 .. 86 93 94 95 96 97 .. Last Next »