Reviews for Giving Up |
---|
daled73 chapter 34 . 11/12/2024 Well done. |
javiermnb chapter 34 . 11/9/2024 gracias por la historia, al princio me aburrio por leer todo los primeros 3 aƱos pero luego le emcontre el gusto. que gran final. El desarrollo de los personajes gracias por esta historia. y felicidades por tu familia. aunque no le entiendas |
James Palmer1 chapter 34 . 11/8/2024 man this had me in my feels. excellent fic, thank you! |
Ukarnian chapter 34 . 11/7/2024 An absolutely brilliant fic, I really hope you decide to write more in the future. Thank you! |
Guest chapter 1 . 11/4/2024 One of the most original in some time only other on my list for the year "Dear Order" by WolfgangNH |
Hedwig68 chapter 34 . 11/1/2024 What a truly amazing story, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this, Thank you. |
Tagrin chapter 34 . 10/24/2024 An excellent story that kept me reading until the end |
Techno Blade chapter 19 . 10/17/2024 I never die. I never cry. Damn you! You made me cry! |
jrjsmith0 chapter 26 . 10/15/2024 I get Harry is frustrated but just abadoning everyone to die? |
John Maitland chapter 1 . 10/2/2024 I have met girls with blood malediction curses before during my 955 (and counting) years as an immortal warrior against the forces of evil. Some I've been able to cure, some I haven't. Yet I have tremendous respect for Astoria Greengrass. She's aware of her condition, but possesses the TRUE nobility of spirit and bravery that Godric looked for in his handpicked students. Ronald Weasley is no Gryffindor. Hell, he shouldn't even BE in Hogwarts. He should've been educated in a muggle school, and FORCED to work. |
Guest chapter 34 . 10/1/2024 What a story from start to finish it was amazing. Keep up the great work and can't wait to read more of you work. |
Guest chapter 34 . 9/30/2024 I love this story. It's my first Haphne. I binged it since yesterday. It's been an emotional rollercoaster - you have a way with painting a picture that just makes me feel so moved I can't help but cycle emotions with the tension. Congratulations on your daughter! I'll admit I got worried at chapter 30 when you weren't sure how this would end because I try to only read completed works. I'm glad it's finished. I do sorta wish ends were tied up a bit better - did Ron just resolve to hate Harry forever, or did he just disappear after 4th year? Did Snape kill Voldemort and Dumbledore? Did Rita move on to something new after Daphne? Does she still work at the prophet? Do Harry and Daphne make new friends in America other than Yen? Does Harry get a job? Does he find a mind healer to help him learn to make healthy relationships? But...I'll live. I'll tell myself everyone important gets the happy ever after. |
Guest chapter 25 . 9/30/2024 I walked in to chapter one thinking the pacing was off because this was setting up to be super long. By chapter five I noticed the word count and realized this is an epic. I'm hoping the next arc has more healing. |
hpreader1974 chapter 34 . 10/2/2024 Great story! One of the better ones I have read in a while. Hope to see more from you. Bill |
MRGwrites chapter 32 . 9/28/2024 so, the mentally deficient Harry from other fics rears his ugly head, you know you've written a very competent and confident Harry until now, it was fun while it lasted... |