Reviews for What I Would Give You
kiwismakemehappy chapter 1 . 9/7/2008
These are really awesome! I like the fact that you didn't just do the common points of view. You used the hobbits which is really cool, and you gave each person their own voice. So... spendid job! And the whole thing rings very true.
Maureen chapter 4 . 10/6/2003
This is a pretty interesting series of vignettes, to my mind. Are you going to do more? The contrast of moods and attitudes is very nice.

One thing: it's "Namarie". (Have you ever heard the recording of Tolkien chanting Galadriel's farewell? Haunting and odd...)

glitteratiglue chapter 4 . 10/3/2003
Aw, these are beautifully written! Wonderful vocabulary used and they are well-crafted. Well done! :)