Reviews for The Gotham Knights of Middle Earth
Coral Skipper chapter 41 . 3/7/2006
Another good chapter. The scene with Death disturbed the fanboy in me because when dealing with DC characters I'm used to seeing Death of the Endless as the portrayel. Aside from that it was excellent. I also don't like the situation because it has passing resemblence to godawful last issue of Batgirl. Thankfully it was only passing.
Kusco chapter 41 . 3/6/2006
Well I must say you've got the gears in my brain turning double time. There was some remarkably cryptic language between Death and Batgirl. Actually its Death in general that has me intrigued. He never actually said anything about "death" or "heaven" and "hell" or even "afterlife" or anything that directly references being dead. Instead he tells Batgirl he's to take her to where she belongs. And when he talks about him he doesn't say Tim will die he says "Tim's time on Middle Earth will soon be over."

Could "dying" be the way off of Middle Earth for Batgirl and Robin?

Probably a crack pot idea. I also thought that Death gave off a remarkably "Batmanish" vibe. But that's probably just the way you described him and me reading into things.

Well beyond the little mysteries that exist in the story. I have to say that this was fun chapter. I always do enjoy seeing Tim get a Batman vibe himself. I alwasy thought that of all the Robin's he'd make the best Batman.

Once again great chapter and I hope to see more soon!
XinnLajgin chapter 41 . 3/6/2006
O.k Batgirl makes a deal with death. I get that and all but are they really gonna die soon? I mean really if you live for an eternity what is the definition of soon. I mean theres no such thing as a completely happy ending but don't those two deserve the next best thing?
RLeigh chapter 41 . 3/6/2006
Ach! Never scare me like that again! Great chapter. Glad to see that Cassie's off the chopping block...for now.

And your correct, Willingham is doing a horrible job on Robin. If you can supply the hardback copy of 'Fables', I know some people who know some people that can kidnap ol' Bill. He's going to be on Fanboy Radio next week, btw. So tempted to call in with a death threat...

Can't wait for the next chapter :)

trecebo chapter 41 . 3/6/2006
Silly ffnet...

I was trying so hard to get to this and read and now, I have. Loved the Bill and Ted shout out. B&T rule, of course.

I just wonder how this little bargain will play out in the future. I was a bit confused, because it occured to me that 'Death' was trying to remove her from ME to Gotham, where she belonged and I didn't think she made that connection. So, thus, my conundrum. She deals to hang out in ME for longer but something fishy this way comes...

Also, the word sequel is a great balm to any anticipated character deaths. Hobbits in Gotham...that'd be...well, weird but if anyone could do it, you could. Not that you are. Just a random plot bunny on my part.
Theo O'Malley chapter 41 . 3/5/2006
Okay, so Cassie isn't dead...for now. You're hovering between 150 and 200 percent. But this freaking story STILL has me so far on the edge of my seat that I'm about to fall off. What's up with the Grim Reaper?



Theo Gary

(falls off seat)

Diviner chapter 40 . 2/22/2006
Excellent story. I can't wait to see how it ends.
Theo O'Malley chapter 40 . 2/20/2006


I swear of you killed Cassie...well...I'd say I'm going to kill you but then I'd never find out what happend next...BUT I'M GOING TO SEND THE STINKIENT ORCS IN MORDOR TO YOUR HOME!



Theo Gary
Proponent of EVO chapter 40 . 2/17/2006



(big gulp of air)


You sir, are evil.
Gundum M chapter 40 . 2/15/2006
somehow i don't think batgirl is gona stay dead very long. especilly since this is a comic book crossover.
Coral Skipper chapter 40 . 2/14/2006
Another good chapter. It had my heart racing like it is at the end of an issue of Infinite Crisis, comic going right now.

Willingham isn't that bad of writer. DoV was decent, and Fables is my favorite ongoing series. Unfortunatly the guy shouldn't be let near Tim ever again. Its embaressing what happened during that time period.
Kusco chapter 40 . 2/14/2006
Oh you cruel cruel person! Leaving us with a cliffhanger like that! Good Golly I love this story! Where to start? Robin vs the Dragon rocked. I loved how you intigrated everything for this battle. When you had the Witch-King get off his fell beast I kept wondering how you were going to kill Theoden or even if you would considering you saved Haladir (rightly so I might add). But you didn't disappoint in the least. The fight went exactly the way I thought it should. You had both Robin and Batgirl doing what they did best but the still didn't outshine the LotR characters. Eowyn and Merry still had their moments. Now I've just got two questions on mind. First is obviously whether Batgirl is dead. Second is if they would actually return to Gotham. I can see it very much right now that they don't. But either way I eagerly await the next chapter!
Alia G. L chapter 40 . 2/14/2006
NO! You can't do that! You can't kill her and you can't leave us in suspense. That is not fair! *sighs in frustration* However, it was an excellent chapter. I love the way you weave Batgirl and Robin into the whole LOTR narrative. Very good. And I am glad Klarion is gone, though how will they get back now? So many questions. Anyway, excellent chapter. Please post the next one soon!
halberd chapter 40 . 2/14/2006
Oh... Dear... God...

Cassie better not be dead or I will virtually pound you to a bloody pulp, kill you, bring you back to life and repeat the process over again.

But, except for that part, awesome chapter! I'm gripping the edge of my set, waiting for more!

This is completely and utterly amazing. I must have said this like five times already, but I can't get over how well you wrote this.

I'll be waiting (im)patiently for more!

With lots of fangirl-ish squeals,

XinnLajgin chapter 40 . 2/13/2006
.:Holding back tears:. Now you absolutly have to update soon. The cliffys are killing me. What will happen to the dynamic duo if they survive that is? And if you say they become the knights of middle earth so help me I'm gonna hurt you.
485 | « Prev Page 1 .. 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 21 .. Last Next »