Reviews for Celebrian's Tale
FlokiDoesNotWantToBeImprecise chapter 1 . 2/22/2012
A great story. Very well written.
Estelle Tiniwiel chapter 1 . 10/25/2009
I can't believe that you've only got one review for this so far! It needs far more praise than that.

I think that it is a beautifully written piece, full of emotion without being too sickly-sweet sentimental. And I also think that you have achieved something which is rarely seen in any fanfiction, which is that same sense of storytelling and the tone of recollection and relaying of old legends that is so characteristic of Tolkien's works. I truly think that this is an excellent piece, and hope that over time more people will pick this story up and review and appreciate it; you deserve it.

A wonderful telling of a tragic story, definitely one that I will be adding to my favourites.

Estelle Tiniwiel -x-
Erestor chapter 1 . 1/19/2004
Brilliant writing, showing a good knowledge of Middle-Earth and it's history. Pity there was no Glorfindel.