|Reviews for Elanor's Revenge|
| Guest chapter 37 . 2/20
I loved this story. Often the sounds as though I am reading it from a published book. The story line is generally well paced, although at times can be slow if you have little time and you are dying to know what happens next (like me;-)). Well done
| Guest chapter 18 . 2/13
I first wish to say that this is a WONDERFUL story. Literally the BEST haldir fic on this sight! You have an incredible style if writing that rivals the skill of many great authors I've read before. I have already read this story twice because it's so good, but there's just one thing that I must get off my chest this time around!
How terrible can Elanor be at archery? I only feel justified in my annoyance because I do participate in archery myself. I have two compound bows, with a rest and sights. I don't consider myself to be amazing, but it just seems improbable for an elf (the most graceful/athletic/awesome creatures middle earth has ever known) to shoot for an hour a day and still be so terrible. Sometimes I shoot without my sights and am still a decent shot, so I can relate to not having sights like her. I even can shoot left handed with success, so how is it that and elf cannot hold a proper stance or almost drops the bow?! Never have I lost my grip on any bow I have used, an early release is understandable when you increase draw weight, but I just think it exaggerated for her to be so terrible! I know it is a plot portion, but come on, with her practice, fine crafted tools, and race she could at least seem believable!
I truly adore this story, but reading her dramatic archery struggles just annoy me. I am also a female too so no gender difference either.
Well I desperatly needed that off my chest, complaint made! The only one I have with this great story!
| Guest chapter 37 . 1/31
Love this story! Can't wait for a Lana love story, and I've tried looking for Mari's Song on your yahoo group and can't locate it. Any help would be appreciated cause I love your fan fictions.
| OPOSOJOJ chapter 13 . 12/18/2013
Finally! Loved the lemon!
| OPOSOJOJ chapter 10 . 12/17/2013
Still loving it! I was hoping for the discipline, maybe it is still to come ;)
| OPOSOJOJ chapter 6 . 12/16/2013
Seriously loving this story so far! Can't wait to continue!
| Bella-Macabre chapter 37 . 12/15/2013
I've never read a Haldir/OC story but I greatly enjoyed this one. Thanks for posting it )
| Wanderer of the Roads chapter 1 . 12/5/2013
I love this story. I remember I read it a long, long time ago and I'm not sure if I reviewed then, but I re-discovered this and I have to congratulate you on writing an amazing piece of work. You have in fact inspired me to write my own Haldir fic, something that I've wanted to do a long time which I finally have time for! I will be back to leave more detailed feedback! Wanderer x
| Enchanted0ne chapter 37 . 8/19/2013
This. Is. Awesome! XD I love it! Im going to go check out your other stories in just a minute ;)
Wonderful job, I was entertained.
| Vana chapter 1 . 7/19/2013
This reads very smoothly. How do you do it?
| Neleothesze chapter 37 . 7/7/2013
This was an amazing story. You two are incredibly talented authors.
| LeafDragonSamurai chapter 37 . 4/1/2013
I am so in love with this fanfic thanks so much for creating it
| vikingdogdemon chapter 37 . 2/3/2013
Thank you so much for such a wonderful story! I was a little intimidated by the length when I began reading it, but I never got bored. Your character development is fantastic. It's a perfect romance and the love scenes are skillfully done. I hope to be able to read more of you writing in the future! :)
| Tinkirbell chapter 37 . 1/22/2013
That was beautifully written! Loved it!
| Infinite101 chapter 1 . 1/1/2013
This is the first Haldir fic I'd ever read and I've been enchanted with the Haldir/oc pairing ever since, its been a while since I've read this fic but I've found myself wanting to reread it for the 3rd time,
A brilliant OC and one of my fave fanfics, looking forward to reading this again, this is one of the best lotr fanfics I've read :)