|Reviews for What He Said, She Said|
| Unnamed chapter 12 . 1/26
Wow it was awesome
| Maria-Reynne chapter 12 . 5/10/2015
One of the best I've read in this section. It was such a bittersweet ending. I feel sorry for Jin that I shed a few tears.
Kudos to you!
| PhanthomHigh chapter 12 . 2/29/2012
I really love your fanfic and the second farewell is making me cry
| Jessikitt chapter 12 . 3/26/2010
I really like the story esp hw u made characters like Maya the ending, I was sad because Jin never said anything about his feeling before he died,poor I really like it
| eunice.heart chapter 12 . 6/8/2009
really awesome story. i can tell u put a lot of work into it and it shows. i really enjoyed. :)
| nitaBonita chapter 12 . 4/13/2008
i really lyked this fic! the second farewell made me cry though lol im a sap for a good romance story!
| dela490 chapter 12 . 4/11/2008
Hello, I would like to say that I read your story and I really love it. Even if I was a little sad about Jin who died at the end. I would like to say congratulation for your imagination and the way you introduced the different characters of the manga and you have change certain thing about the link of the characters. for example, made botan, yusuke's cousin, etc. Really this is a very good story.
| Senshi's Tenshi chapter 12 . 1/12/2008
I must say, I'm in love with this story! The title works so well, especially with your line "What he said, she said too." Is that where that came from? At first, I thought the title meant the phrase of "monkey see, monkey do" but with words rather than action.
Jin's character made me so sad. To love dying in the shadows. That's so painful and heart-wrenching, especially when Yukina wanted them to be together. She would have reciprocated if she had know. Yet, if she let Jin go first at the hospital...I wonder. Normally, all the side characters have the same role or the main role. In this fic, Jin was a side character with almost a main role, making him a strong part of the fic.
I don't understand Kurama saying "how bittersweet it must be for him seeing his friends in love and alive," at the end of the fic, last chapter. The alive part makes me wonder if Kurama was informed about Jin's condition. If everyone but Yukina and possibly Kuwabara were informed. Kurama also mentions that what Jin did, not telling Yukina his feelings, would be good 'in the long run.' But Kuronue talks about going drinking. I'm just wondering, since Jin said he had a first case and if he had told his friends about it, since he lived through it.
It is a happy ending, but right with Jin's feelings at the end, if was saddening. It was a joyous for everyone to be engaged or getting there, but a regret on lost love.
Whatever did happen to Karasu? I mean dead or alive wise. I would think Yuusuke would still find him and kick his ass if he were alive or not in the hospital after whatever Toguro had done to him, that Kurama already hadn't.
You have great initiative and understanding of character development. For an AU storyline, the double meanings and details were incredible! I'll be looking into more of your work. It's been so long since I found a writer with originality and completed fics. The only thing I can find fault with is grammar, but it really doesn't matter. Especially with so much writing put into each chapter. Thanks for the good reads!
P.S. I didn't realize I had my PMs disabled. Just incase you tried to PM me back. :D
| Bookish Cupcake chapter 11 . 11/9/2007
How sweet yet sad U-U
| Bookish Cupcake chapter 9 . 11/8/2007
OH! Drama! I'll read more in the morning
| animevideogame freak chapter 12 . 10/3/2007
i really liked the story and i was so sad for jin though i was hoping he would get with yukina cuz i liked how you had their characters it was also sad that he had lukemia i almost cried when i read that so sad. the story was good though remember i said that lol
| Taz chapter 12 . 3/13/2007
This story is GREAT AND AWESOME. I wish Jin could be happy though. But still amazing story. Oh and this is my rewiew for all the chapters.
| khryzle kawaii chapter 12 . 12/30/2006
Im kinda sad that it seemed like ur killing jin-san in this story...i personally love his relationship here with yukina and had wished that the two would end up together and that jin would find cure about his disease, everything is possible if u write a fanfic anyway. im just kinda dissapointed about their relationship but i want to congratulate you for a job well done. u just rose my adoration to this couple.
thank you so much for sharing this and have a nice day.
| khryzle kawaii chapter 10 . 12/29/2006
pretty good story...i love how you wrote it...and the characters involved are facinating and the surnames to put in them..haha its like a big YYH reunion! i love it!
thanks for this!
| Smexy Kitten chapter 12 . 8/29/2006
once again, this was another fantastic epic of a fic! i mean, honestly, you have outdone yourself w/ this one. each and every chapter had me blown away. you even found a way to incorporate the majority of the characters that were most memorable from the show and mention each person at least once. i also loved how you surprised all of your readers with the little romance between jin and yukina. i can honestly say that i liked that aspect of your story a lot.
this is yet again, another wonderful kurama and botan fic that should (and will) definitely go down in history!