Reviews for First Knight
panther73110 chapter 1 . 10/14/2020
I wished this had been finished as it was one of my favorites
tinfoilchef chapter 1 . 5/28/2020
Good story but I see something of a continuity issue.

At the beginning of the story she's got the scythe. When talking to Whistler and while talking to Ereinion Gil-galadshe still has it. She was holding it when she went through the portal to Lorien. I was surprised that there was no further mention of it at all.

If she still had it in Middle Earth, the elves would have had a high regard for it because few weapons in Middle Earth could be called it's equal. On the other hand had she arrived without it, Buffy would have been rather upset at losing a weapon that was literally destined for her.
SW chapter 57 . 4/16/2020
It has been some 12 years since I first found this story, and to this day it is undeniably one of my favorites. Should you ever feel the inclination to finish it, I and many others would be much appreciative, but if you, as I suspect, have moved away from fan-fiction more permanently, please know, that I am one of many who are grateful for this magnificent work you have done.
Thank you.
Guest chapter 57 . 3/28/2020
I was 17 when chapter 57 was posted. I'm now 30. And I still keep coming back to this fic, re-reading it from time to time. To me it's one of the best fics ever written.

I don't know what happened to you, hopefully just life in general, but even after all these years I still long for this story to have an end. In another ten years, I'll probably be still re-reading it.
Adelphia1928 chapter 57 . 9/24/2019
Wow. This entire fic is amazing! I've raced though it in just under three days. It's kept me up at night and gotten my up early each day in joy. I love how you balance humor and terror. I love how even with Buffy here it doesn't feel like victory is assured, you can still feel the peril they are all in. I love watching Aragon and Buffy slowly grow closer, though I wonder still who sent that dream to him. Thank you for sharing this with us. It's been wonderful to read!
StardustDragon427 chapter 1 . 8/5/2019
I reread this story at least twice a year. I love it, I know it has been a while but I really hope you can finish it. if you cant thats alright but still. thank you for an amazing adventure with buffy
long time reader chapter 57 . 6/22/2019
It's June 2019 and I just finished my somewhat annual re-reading of this story. I hope all is well with you and that someday you finish this epic-length story!
Wynter Phoenix chapter 6 . 1/19/2018
I always read this story at least once a year and I still love it. Hope one day you'll be able to finish it. Xoxo
Avalonemyst chapter 57 . 11/26/2016
Very enjoyable. Realistic characters, good battle scenes.
Avalonemyst chapter 40 . 11/25/2016
Very enjoyable chapter.
Wynter Phoenix chapter 1 . 9/19/2016
I have loved this story since the first time I read it many years ago. I always check here and there, hoping to see a new chapter. I really hope you finish this!
tadah2 chapter 1 . 8/26/2016
This is pretty awesome!
Guest chapter 1 . 6/10/2016
It's been ten long years what's up
long time reader chapter 57 . 2/13/2016
it's been a long time since this fic was updated but it's always been a favorite. i hope that some day you update this or check back here and see all the people who still love this story!
Guest chapter 57 . 3/28/2015
So what is the rest of the Fellowship's reaction going to be when Boromir shows up with an army at his back to help?
Babydoll9150
2,612 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »