|Reviews for The Great Middle Earth Game Show|
| x-Rose-Tyler-x chapter 4 . 8/2/2005
This is absolutely brilliant!
| Sam chapter 1 . 2/9/2005
Hi guys! that was very funny! I loved it! keep up the good work. See u soon.
oh yeah one more thing...
| IrethAncalime3791 chapter 4 . 9/25/2004
Good chapter, enjoyed it much!
Ireth the Self-acclaimed Maia
| Wolf chapter 4 . 9/23/2004
you're an Eomer fan aint ya...yeh, thought, personally i think he's just a little bit scary...
| Wolf chapter 1 . 9/23/2004
no, wait the ultimate bad guy is...wait for it...DARTH VADER! i mean he tried to kill his...wait...aw drat, fine, yes i get the point...*begins to mutter incoherently*
| Noldo chapter 4 . 9/23/2004
Liked 'Who's the greatest king in all Middle-Earth'. Personally, I'd have said 'Fingolfin', but Aragorn will do for the live 'uns.
Gandalf should really learn that not everyone's his brother. It'sd do him and Boromir a world of good.
Saruman's sarcasm seems to have backfired [as well as being awesome alliteration (tm)].
By the way, thanks for the review on 'In Defence of Good Lord Denethor' - Fanfiction dot Net took it down for not being a story, so I think I'll upload it onto HASA later. Look for 'Noldo' :D
| Noldo chapter 3 . 8/17/2004
Another funny chapter.
Wow, the audience seems rather pro-Sam today. Good for them. I always thought Sam rather got the short end of the stick...
Boromir isn't the only one who talks to himself! I do it too!
Pippin eating scarves? Why does that remind me of Erestor's 'What Really Happened'?
Poor Faramir. The bookish guys always get the trouble. *huggles Faramir*
Faramir IS Boromir's brother. Silly Gandalf. He shouldn't overestimate *some* people's mental capacity...
Certain species of rabid quadrupeds. A sublime description.
| Noldo chapter 2 . 8/17/2004
Agh! I missed this! Bad Noldo! Bad, bad, bad!
Please don't take offence about the errors or anything. I do the same thing to everyone. :D
Aragorn and Arwen are a very soppy couple, aren't they? 'Lovecakes'... How about 'pookie'?
It's kind of rude for me to keep on at these errors, I guess, but where you've put 'Boromir looked as if he would loose his lunch at any moment', you should replace 'loose' with 'lose'.
It's good that you found the chapter. It's funny. I like Denethor and Eomer's brawl.
Denethor always gets portrayed as a pyro, doesn't he? It's not that it isn't funny, but I think that I liked him better in 'Fallaciously Framed' (no offence).
| Lindariel H chapter 3 . 8/6/2004
That was the funniest fanfic I have read so far! Write more!
| Sarah chapter 3 . 8/5/2004
Hey this was really funny I like Denethor being a pyromaniac. And I love the part with Faramir and Boromir there are my favs hope you update soon its wonderful so far!
| IrethAncalime3791 chapter 3 . 8/5/2004
Yes, this is quite soon enough. And when you put "Saruman" and "sarcastic" in the same sentence, I started getting quite hopeful. But alas, it was not fated for this chapter. Perhaps the next? *wiggles eyebrows meaningfully*
However, I loved this chapter as much as the others.
-"Uh...he's still MY brother," Boromir pointed out intelligently.- Indeed. Ha ha, I loved that one. And Denethor and Frodo's little spat.
And the last part with Gandalf was excellent. Loved every second while reading it.
Do post a fourth chapter-featuring Saruman the Sarcastic, if you please!
Ireth the Self-acclaimed Maia
| Erestor chapter 3 . 8/5/2004
This was my favorite chapter so far. I like sarcasm, you see, and there was lots of it in here. You're going to turn Saruman into my favorite character.
I still like Sam very much. It seems as if the audience is filled with Sam fans. It's great to read a story in which the hobbit is not stupid, fat, or ugly, but is instead sensible and loved.
Please tell Frodo that Boromir is not stupid.
| Celias23 chapter 3 . 8/5/2004
This chapter was the best! i loved the parts with Eomer, Faramir, and Boromir:D! (they're my favorite:P) i URGE you to keep writing! Maybe make to chapters a little longer, they're really fun to read. Hannon lle!
| Celias23 chapter 2 . 8/4/2004
Aw man, this was extremly amusing! please, continue writing!
| Erestor chapter 2 . 8/3/2004
I'm so glad you found this. It is quite funny, and I especially liked the part with Sam and his frying-pan. And Denethor is great too.