Hi! I’m not sure if you still read the comments, but I wanted to let you know that I enjoyed this story immensely. I have read it in a couple of days and it had such a LOTR-feeling about it, made me very happy. The only thing I regret is the minor character of Eomer/Emmet, it’s personal but I really like his character and all the Eomer/Lothiriel fics as well. But maybe they will play a minor role in part 2 and 3.

A fun story

Thank you for taking me on this journey. The ending was satisfying and no body had to die. Most modern AU type things never really seem to work out for me, but perhaps this one was truly out of the ordinary, for it has become one of my favorite fanfics ever; thank you so much.

Oh no I don't want to watch Boromir die again but this will get his memories back won't it urrgghh

Hoo boy, the plot thickens.

Haldir's back!

Now that we have a Gimli, I'm really hoping we'll get out hobbits in there soon, eh?

Oooh, Adrigorn has a plan...

Yesss! Haldir!

Very excited for Haldir, but... Where's Gimli? There's no Gimli yet! Is it because he's still alive in Valinor?

I'm even more excited than before, if that's even possible; Éowyn and Faramir have their memories back in very excited you have no idea.

Oh boy oh boy oh boy oh boy we got memories resurfacing oh boy oh boy oh boy

I KNEW IT I FREAKING KNEW IT!

Ooooh, the plot thickens...
At this point in the story, I'm pretty sure I'll end up reading the whole thing in one day.

This story was written more than a decade ago, so I've found it a little late... but it is absolutely amazing! One of the best Lord of the Rings fanfics I've ever read.