oh lord somebody keep an eye on filch hes turning into gollum

Dying at how smooth Remus is

So, is she a teacher, or... Guess I will find out. The part where Lora spoke like a Jedi was quit amusing. It will be interesting to see how she uses it further in the story. Thank you for this chapter :)

A barmy one coming right up! Thank you for this chapter! :)

"...any character's resemblance to a certain pop star..." Haha! X) Well, the story seems interesting so far. I think I may continue reading. Thank you for this chapter :)

I love your book! I especially like the fact that you used so many language. Thank you so much for using Gaedhlig, so few people appreciate it these days. You translated Chi Mi Na Morbheanna!
But all in all, THANK YOU FOR WRITING SUCH A WONDERFUL STORY AND ALLOWING EVERYBODY TO READ IT!

I love 'Phantom of the Opera'

Oh my God, I'm sooo excited bout' this fanfic

From the last chapter I live the Mushu reference...please tell me that's from Mulan:). My six year old quotes Mushu all the time. And I love the LOTR reference. Aragorn all scruffy definitely appeals to me. He definitely should have come straight from fighting orcs to be crowned.

I honestly love the idea of Remus and Severus having some sort of friendship...I like to think that Remus was the least hated Marauder of Snape. I am taking a look at the version of this story on . That story seems a bit more stream-lined and to the point (pared down, maybe?).

Ok, so Ron and Harry's "you are a prat" "I am a prat" exchange made me laugh out loud:). In the chaos of my life with five kids (one of whom is a baby and likes to pretend he still doesn't know how to sleep through the night;) I don't always get LOL moments in the middle of my day, so thank you!

Ok, this chapter made my day. Tonks always makes me happy, I love Lorelei' s defense voice, and the Spice Girls reference was cute:). Also, Snape was great in this chapter, I love how he goes between being utterly distracted by Lorelei to being determined to get her sacked.

Alright, my love of Severus Snape and my wish for his happiness brought me to reading this story next:).

Here's the end-of-story review I promised.

I really, really loved all the LOTR / Hobbit references; I'm a huge fan and it was so cool to read about Bag End and all those other things. I also liked the selkies; the whole concept of their otherworldly beauty and their kindness. The idea of Lorelei having many Selkie half-brothers who seem to love her is endearing. I like the characters of Tynan, Kieran, and Cassandra, and the romance between the latter two. The quotes from Shakespeare, Jane Austen, and the Princess Bride brought a smile to my face; it was all very romantic.

The beginning of Snape and Lorelei's relationship seemed to have escalated a bit quickly; also, I feel that Lily was not given enough attention in this fic. As she was Severus's first love, I feel that perhaps he would have trouble letting go of her first. Also, though I am aware that this fic was written years and years ago, somehow Dumbledore and Minerva's relationship disturbs me a bit, seeing as Dumbledore is gay.

Other than those few factors, this story was a fascinating read. Thanks for sharing it :)

Never in my LIFE have I ever read a fic wherein I despised Harry so much... He was downright rapey in some places, I swear. Good work with making absolutely annoying and detestable (that's a compliment) — but I'll stick with Nice Harry, thanks very much.

I was going to save my review for the end, so I wouldn't bombard you with forty reviews, but I couldn't resist. So far, this story is pretty good. :)